By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - The Official Wheel of Time Thread (UNMARKED SPOILERS FOR ENTIRE SERIES)

Kantor said:
Mummelmann said:
Tried to get into this series since a lot of my friends love it but I just couldn't. Read the first two books and fell off entirely. All in all, I haven't enjoyed High Fantasy for many years.

You haven't read nearly long enough for it to start getting good. Most of the early books is Rand, Mat and Perrin whining and moaning about their power and how they can't handle it. They get over that by about halfway through the series.


If I've read 1500 pages into a series and it hasn't "started getting good" then there's something wrong with the series, in my honest opinion. If an author cannot produce an incentive for me to feel excited after two massive novels and keep me tied to the series, he has ultimately failed. I see a lot of people making the same defense for this and others series but for me its as simple as this; if a series doesn't start good and draw me in at all, I won't stick around and keep reading simply out of courtesy or the hope that one day, a worthwhile novel might emerge somewhere in the line. Same with TV shows, if seasons 1 and 2 aren't any good, I simply don't want to watch them.

I think the fact of the matter is that I suffer from a two-fold problem here; I never liked Jordan's style or setting at all, and I think I simply grew tired of High Fantasy along the way.



Around the Network
Mummelmann said:
Kantor said:
Mummelmann said:
Tried to get into this series since a lot of my friends love it but I just couldn't. Read the first two books and fell off entirely. All in all, I haven't enjoyed High Fantasy for many years.

You haven't read nearly long enough for it to start getting good. Most of the early books is Rand, Mat and Perrin whining and moaning about their power and how they can't handle it. They get over that by about halfway through the series.


If I've read 1500 pages into a series and it hasn't "started getting good" then there's something wrong with the series, in my honest opinion. If an author cannot produce an incentive for me to feel excited after two massive novels and keep me tied to the series, he has ultimately failed. I see a lot of people making the same defense for this and others series but for me its as simple as this; if a series doesn't start good and draw me in at all, I won't stick around and keep reading simply out of courtesy or the hope that one day, a worthwhile novel might emerge somewhere in the line. Same with TV shows, if seasons 1 and 2 aren't any good, I simply don't want to watch them.

I think the fact of the matter is that I suffer from a two-fold problem here; I never liked Jordan's style or setting at all, and I think I simply grew tired of High Fantasy along the way.

Well, it's up to you, but you're the one missing out. The final trilogy, especially, is absolutely outstanding.

Though if you were getting bored by books 1 and 2, you would never have been able to sit through Book 10.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Kantor said:

On the last novel in particular:

  • On the whole, I was very impressed. I enjoyed it a great deal.
  • Logain's moment where he stops to help the children instead of recovering the sa'angreal nearly brought a tear to my eye.
  • Lan's battle with Demandred was great. Gawyn and Galad's battles, on the other hand, were pointless.
  • I was actually a little sad about Demandred. He and Ishamael are the only two Forsaken I've ever sympathised with. And he never got his showdown with Lews Therin.
  • WHY THE HELL did we hear literally nothing about Demandred in Shara? Could he not have replaced 500 pages of Elayne bickering with the Kin or 3000 pages of Perrin pining for Faile with some of that?
  • It would have been cool if Ishamael had realised that the Dark One was misleading him the whole time, allied with Rand and turned on him. But hey, that's a different story.
  • The Flame of Tar Valon came out of literally nowhere and I don't see why Egwene needed to die for it
  • Rand's rebirth makes little to no sense, but hey, I'm just glad he's alive. So is he going to go all Jain Farstrider and wander the world now, ignoring all of his friends and his three lovers?
  • Mat really came into his own in this novel. Major respect.
  • Mazrim being a leading Darkfriend was so obvious it was kind of sad. I was hoping for it to be subverted.
  • I don't really see why Moiraine was so essential to the victory. She didn't really do anything. She kind of helped break up the tension between Egwene and Rand and then just acted as a pool of saidar for a few seconds, which any female channeler could have done.
  • Seriously why was Alanna even in this series? She has done nothing of any significance ever.
  • Perrin didn't make me want to punch him in the face, which is a huge improvement. I silently cheered when he snapped Lanfear's neck.

On the Dark One:

  • I think this got a little bit muddled.
  • Rand says a couple of books earlier that the Pattern is balanced, and that the Dark One needs to be killed to restore that balance.
  • But then he sees that the Dark One is the balance. So I suppose he was just completely wrong the first time?
  • But then why is there a bubble of protection and light around Rand that unspoils food?
  • I posted this on reddit, and the most satisfying answer I saw was that the Dark One does provide balance to the world when he is securely imprisoned, but when the Bore was open, or the seals weak, he had far too much corrupting influence over the world. That influence needed to be reduced, but not eliminated.

I would have liked to have Faile actually die.  I think Perrins character deserved to suffer for being so lame

I forgot how they had built Moraine up to be the savior of the world.  You are right, all she did was ease tensions between Egwene and Rand, which I guess is the part where she saved the world... 

Seriously, the Shara thing was Awesome and should have been explored earlier.  Instead of pointless plot threads about Perrin losing his wife, for three freaking books, should have had Perrin do something significant, like go to Shara.  Then, maybe people would like him...  Seriously, Perrin didn't even do that much wolfish stuff in the final book.  The wolves just kind of did their own thing...  Also, since walking on a twig in the blight can kill you... how did the wolves get to shayol ghul?  

The flame of tar valon was weird, but I do think Egwene's death was one of the highlights of the series.  Also, if you think about it, she is the only original character to die of the ones that fled Edmonds field.  Her death helped make the battle real, but others should have died as well.  Not that scary of a last battle if almost all of your main characters survive it...

About the dark one... There are some aspects of how it was handled that I thought worked really well.  The fact that the dark one is needed to balance the wheel makes sense, but then the opposite would need to be true as well, the dragon would need to always be.  The dragon is tied to the wheel and is reborn, but he dies.  If one force is needed for balance and can't be killed, wouldn't the same be true for the opposite force?  Perhaps it is implied that the creater is that force, but uses the dragon as his tool?  

Also, I don't understand how Rand could remember the dark one being vulnerable to being killed before, but not remember why he didn't kill the dark one.  



Kantor said:
gergroy said:

I also did not like the Rand switching bodies at the end.  I think it would have been a more powerful ending if he had actually died.  

I would be inclined to agree with you. But I don't think he should have died.

He should have stayed in the Rand body and gained the powers that he managed to gain. He is essentially the avatar of the Creator in the mortal world.


But as avatar of the creator his purpose was accomplished.  If Rand had stayed around, he would upset the balance of power in the world.  He was way too powerful, especially with his ties to Mat, Perrin, and Elayne, he would essentially be ruling the world.  

Besides, in order to truly make his act of defeating the dark one monumentous, sacrifice was needed.  The way the story is written, that sacrifice was that of Egwene... but that isn't nearly as powerful as if he had sacrificed himself.  Fact is, from the 8 original characters that left edmonds field in the first book, only one died... 



I made this Sporcle quiz on who killed or otherwise defeated each member of the Forsaken. Give it a try!

http://www.sporcle.com/games/Harsalan/wheel-of-time-deaths-of-the-forsaken



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Around the Network
gergroy said:
Kantor said:
gergroy said:

I also did not like the Rand switching bodies at the end.  I think it would have been a more powerful ending if he had actually died.  

I would be inclined to agree with you. But I don't think he should have died.

He should have stayed in the Rand body and gained the powers that he managed to gain. He is essentially the avatar of the Creator in the mortal world.


But as avatar of the creator his purpose was accomplished.  If Rand had stayed around, he would upset the balance of power in the world.  He was way too powerful, especially with his ties to Mat, Perrin, and Elayne, he would essentially be ruling the world.  

Besides, in order to truly make his act of defeating the dark one monumentous, sacrifice was needed.  The way the story is written, that sacrifice was that of Egwene... but that isn't nearly as powerful as if he had sacrificed himself.  Fact is, from the 8 original characters that left edmonds field in the first book, only one died... 

Well, none of the people from Emond's Field really had any reason to die. Not even Egwene.

Nynaeve and Moiraine were safe in Shayol Ghul. Nobody could really harm them there.

Mat's luck would certainly protect him.

Perrin would achieve nothing through his death; he spends most of the book in Tel'aran'rhiod anyway.

Lan surviving a Sheathing the Sword move is a huge inspiration for all of his troops and pushes them onwards.

Thom... okay, Thom didn't really do anything in that series after Eye of the World except occasionally go on sentry duty and help to rescue Moiraine. I was hoping that some huge secret about him would come out - like, he was Jain Farstrider or something - and that would make him significant, but that didn't really happen. As it was, he spend the Last Battle sitting on a rock watching Shayol Ghul.

Rand deserved his rest after everything he had done, and he was pretty specifically told that he would survive. Plus, the fact that he was expecting death makes his survival far more powerful than his death.

Egwene... she could have woven that Flame without killing herself. But if Gawyn had to die, then Egwene had to go with him.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Kantor said:
gergroy said:
Kantor said:
gergroy said:

I also did not like the Rand switching bodies at the end.  I think it would have been a more powerful ending if he had actually died.  

I would be inclined to agree with you. But I don't think he should have died.

He should have stayed in the Rand body and gained the powers that he managed to gain. He is essentially the avatar of the Creator in the mortal world.


But as avatar of the creator his purpose was accomplished.  If Rand had stayed around, he would upset the balance of power in the world.  He was way too powerful, especially with his ties to Mat, Perrin, and Elayne, he would essentially be ruling the world.  

Besides, in order to truly make his act of defeating the dark one monumentous, sacrifice was needed.  The way the story is written, that sacrifice was that of Egwene... but that isn't nearly as powerful as if he had sacrificed himself.  Fact is, from the 8 original characters that left edmonds field in the first book, only one died... 

Well, none of the people from Emond's Field really had any reason to die. Not even Egwene.

Nynaeve and Moiraine were safe in Shayol Ghul. Nobody could really harm them there.

Mat's luck would certainly protect him.

Perrin would achieve nothing through his death; he spends most of the book in Tel'aran'rhiod anyway.

Lan surviving a Sheathing the Sword move is a huge inspiration for all of his troops and pushes them onwards.

Thom... okay, Thom didn't really do anything in that series after Eye of the World except occasionally go on sentry duty and help to rescue Moiraine. I was hoping that some huge secret about him would come out - like, he was Jain Farstrider or something - and that would make him significant, but that didn't really happen. As it was, he spend the Last Battle sitting on a rock watching Shayol Ghul.

Rand deserved his rest after everything he had done, and he was pretty specifically told that he would survive. Plus, the fact that he was expecting death makes his survival far more powerful than his death.

Egwene... she could have woven that Flame without killing herself. But if Gawyn had to die, then Egwene had to go with him.

But Mat gave half his luck away, or something like that...  I think Mat dying at the hands of Padan Fain might have given more credence to that plot thread.  Plus, I just can't picture Mat living with the seanchan for the rest of his life...

Perrin didn't achive much by living either... I guess he killed lanfear...

Lan could have inspired his troops by just killing demandred though, somebody else could have brought demandreds head up to inspire the troops more, didn't have to be lan.  

I did like Thom's casual dispatchment of darkfriends at the mouth of the cave though.  I got a good chuckle out of it.  

I don't know if Rand actually expected to die though, from the ending anyway.  It seems like he had planned on switching bodies.  I mean, the ex damane and him seemed to have planned out a way for him to leave without anybody else knowing.  At least a part of him was planning on living.  

I'm fine with Egwene dying, only problem was the flame of tar valon was kind of out of nowhere.  And what is up with it making everything crystal?  



How about this. What do you guys think of how the roles of woman and men were handled in this series? Jordan got a lot of flack for his treatment of women, do you agree or disagree? why?



gergroy said:
How about this. What do you guys think of how the roles of woman and men were handled in this series? Jordan got a lot of flack for his treatment of women, do you agree or disagree? why?

Well, especially early on in the series, there was something fishy going on. He appeared to think that women did nothing but complain about men the moment they were outside of the company of a man. Nynaeve was genuinely unbearable around book 5 when she would just whine about Thom and Juilin all hours of the day.

He certainly improved a lot towards the end of the series, though.

Also, he does show quite a few matriarchal societies. Andor's monarch is always female; Far Madding bans men from being merchants; Altara has some creepy female-on-male domestic violence overtones; Seanchan has not seen an Emperor for 900 years. I'm not really sure what he was trying to get at here.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Kantor said:
gergroy said:
How about this. What do you guys think of how the roles of woman and men were handled in this series? Jordan got a lot of flack for his treatment of women, do you agree or disagree? why?

Well, especially early on in the series, there was something fishy going on. He appeared to think that women did nothing but complain about men the moment they were outside of the company of a man. Nynaeve was genuinely unbearable around book 5 when she would just whine about Thom and Juilin all hours of the day.

He certainly improved a lot towards the end of the series, though.

Also, he does show quite a few matriarchal societies. Andor's monarch is always female; Far Madding bans men from being merchants; Altara has some creepy female-on-male domestic violence overtones; Seanchan has not seen an Emperor for 900 years. I'm not really sure what he was trying to get at here.


I think he was getting a lot of flack at the beginning and started creating societies where woman dominate.  One issue that I think kind of exemplifies Jordans view of woman in the series is the difference between how men and women use the one power.  

Women gain access to the one power by submitting to it, while men gain access by wrestling control of it.