By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Satoru Iwata implies he may resign if operating income target for next FY is not met

burninmylight said:
forest-spirit said:
Not sure getting rid of Iwata would do much. I have a feeling there are other people over at Nintendo holding the company back, a bunch of old farts living in the past.



Reggie needs to go though. >_> I want Cammie back!


What's so special about Cammy Dunaway? All I remember from her tenure is E3 '09, and that's one I'd like to forget.



only thing I can think of is she is a female in a male dominated business... that e3 was pretty terrible



Around the Network
Max King of the Wild said:
burninmylight said:
forest-spirit said:
Not sure getting rid of Iwata would do much. I have a feeling there are other people over at Nintendo holding the company back, a bunch of old farts living in the past.



Reggie needs to go though. >_> I want Cammie back!


What's so special about Cammy Dunaway? All I remember from her tenure is E3 '09, and that's one I'd like to forget.



only thing I can think of is she is a female in a male dominated business... that e3 was pretty terrible


E3 '09 wasn't that bad.  You must be thinking of '08.  I don't know why people get so hung up on NoA people, all they do is localize and sell what NCL tells them to.  They don't really have any influence or power over anything other than which direction to take the TV ads or what tag-lines to use in press conferences.  All of the decisions about games that affect us as gamers are made by Iwata, Miyamoto and their management team in Kyoto.



The Screamapillar is easily identified by its constant screaming—it even screams in its sleep. The Screamapillar is the favorite food of everything, is sexually attracted to fire, and needs constant reassurance or it will die.

Chandler said:

100% sure that the same quarterly results for Sony would be treated as a landslide victory. It's so hypocritical, Sony doesn't even reveal Vita sales and cuts forecasts by 6 million across two quarters and will cut it even more but somehow their investors just don't give a shit.


what fantasy world do you live in?

http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=SNE+Interactive#symbol=sne;range=2y;compare=;indicator=volume;charttype=area;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=off;source=undefined;



This thread made me start thinking about Iwata and whether I like him or not, and I really do. He's so straight forward, open, honest, and wanting to engage with not only investors but the gamers. The Nintendo Direct speeches, his interviews with developers, and his very frequent speeches are all proof of this. I really appreciate him.

I can't think of a single other CEO in our industry who tries to be so honest, forward, and personable as Iwata.



TripleMMM said:
Sorry to late for this party, but this thing about Iwata hinting of him to resign is down right ludacris! Why would someone hint about it when it's not even shown in the discussion board??? It baffles me to no end...


Iwata resigning =



Around the Network
Soleron said:

I want this to happen. I can't think how Nintendo could be managed worse right now (there being zero games or consoles from them that I want, and poor earnings and sales)

There are plenty of ways they can be managed worse.

There are also obvious ways in which they could have been managed better.



UncleScrooge said:

@ Rest of the thread: What are you guys talking about? Nintendo is not fine, both their console and handheld markets are in severe decline and Iwata, being the CEO and responsible for Nintendo's operations, is to blame for this. Iwata was really smart using Blue Ocean strategy and making their next console a disruptive one - his analysis of the video gaming market in the early 2000's was spot on and his actions well thought out. But after that things just went downhill in every possible regard. Here's some blatant mistakes Nintendo made under Iwata's lead that any mediocre CEO should have been able to avoid:

- Not following up the first waves of mass market games on the Wii with new titles, thus letting the Wii die
- Completely abandoning the mass market with the 3DS
- Pricing the 3DS insanely high just because Iwata himself thought they "could charge that price"
- Not providing a decent line-up in the first year of the 3DS
- Pushing numerous games back in the west and right now acting all surprised the console isn't selling (!)
- Abandoning the customers of the Wii with the Wii U because they wanted to focus on "the core gamer"...
- ... which equals going back to the business strategies that almost bankrupted the company some years ago
- Not providing a decent launch line up for the Wii U despite claiming to have "learned a lesson"

Other things include:
- Not following up Nintendo's growth with the acquisition of new development studios
- The Fallout with EA which will strip Nintendo of any serious EA support for years
- The inability to keep his own developers in check (5 years of Zelda dev cycle, 3D Mario, Pikmin 3 announcement)
- His inability to make sure deadlines are being met (like 50% of the Wii U Q1 line-up was pushed back!!)
- Repeatedly (!) overestimating demand for Nintendo systems in their FY forecasts
- The inability to create an account system for their consoles and the resulting "data transfer" fiasco

--> To sum it all up Iwata (and some of Nintendo's managers and developers) got full of themselves, which is the only possible explanation for some absolutely mindboggling decisions the company made over the last few years. As CEO Iwata's job is to run the company and he's responsible for all of this. Nintendo is looking more and more like Apple did in the 90's: Continuously making questionable business decisions while sitting on a gold mine.

There's little here I could disagree with.

hunter_alien said:

Its not Iwatas fault, I allways believed that he is ready to make Nintendo more flexible, but the rest of the leadership is bringing him down.

Iwata's in charge. If there are obstacles, it is his job to deal with them. You can't even use the "Japanese companies are different" excuse, because no one short of God would have ever stopped Yamauchi from doing what he wanted.



I tend to agree, but that would still mean he's the wrong man for the job, no?



RolStoppable said:
The way I see it, the problem is that Iwata is a too nice guy. He doesn't strike me as the type that pounds his fist on the table and tells his developers to do as he says or otherwise they'll have to look for a new job.

I think that's Miyamoto's job (at least for the projects he works on).



Nintendo and PC gamer

maverick40 said:

The Nintendo Direct was not surprising in the slightest. Wow, a cross over game we know next to nothing of. By the sounds of it will be a niche SRPG that will not be a hardware seller which Nintendo needs btw. What it did show was the lack of 3rd party support the Wii U has but hoepfully that will improve.


Just because the game does not appeal to you means that there is no third party support. As of right now, the Wii U has 6 exclusive third party titles, obviously there could be more but it's only been few months. Besides that Nintendo Direct was ment for games that Nintendo was working on and Iwata said that they would show more third party stuff later on.