Forums - Nintendo Discussion - BEST OVERALL EDITION (2D Mario Platformers) [home console only]

Mario Best 2D adventure

Super Mario Bros
Super Mario Bros 2
Super Mario Bros 3
Super Mario World
NSMB WII
NSMBU
i liked the handhelds better

THE BIG QUESTION MAKE SURE TO VOTE AND POST YOUR ANSWER!


What gave the best performance/most liked/ best delivery in the series?

Discuss

[ Note, Super Mario World 2 doesn't count and AllStars dont count]



Around the Network
I haven't played World much, or NSMB but I would have to choose 3!

World > U > 3 > 1 > rest

Ongoing bet with think-man: He wins if MH4 releases in any shape or form on PSV in 2013, I win if it doesn't.

3 > World > U > Yoshi's Island (yes, it counts) > 1 > 2

 

sperrico87 said:
3 > World > U > Yoshi's Island (yes, it counts) > 1 > 2

↓↓↓Tbone↓↓↓

I swear i was 50-50 on that (SMW2) But then Yoshi island i would of had to count in all the threads!!! It was a good game though!

Mine are

World>>> 3> NSMBU >1> NSMBWII> 2



Around the Network
tbone51 said:

sperrico87 said:
3 > World > U > Yoshi's Island (yes, it counts) > 1 > 2

↓↓↓Tbone↓↓↓

I swear i was 50-50 on that (SMW2) But then Yoshi island i would of had to count in all the threads!!! It was a good game though!

Mine are

World>>> 3> NSMBU >1> NSMBWII> 2


I mean... it says Super Mario World 2 right on the box, it's gotta be counted.



 

Super Mario Bros 3 >> New Super Mario Bros Ds >> New Super Mario Bros 2

 

World>3>64>1>U>2

digitalnasties said:
Super Mario Bros 3 >> New Super Mario Bros Ds >> New Super Mario Bros 2

↓↓↓Tbone↓↓↓

No handhelds there's so many!!!! but SMB3 is very good!



Around the Network

sperrico87 said:



tbone51 said:

sperrico87 said:
3 > World > U > Yoshi's Island (yes, it counts) > 1 > 2

↓↓↓Tbone↓↓↓

I swear i was 50-50 on that (SMW2) But then Yoshi island i would of had to count in all the threads!!! It was a good game though!

Mine are

World>>> 3> NSMBU >1> NSMBWII> 2





I mean... it says Super Mario World 2 right on the box, it's gotta be counted.

↓↓↓Tbone↓↓↓

I kno i kno..... but.... Its Yoshi game!