Forums - Nintendo Discussion - BEST OVERALL EDITION? (Super Smash Bros)

Best of The Best Fighter!

Super Smash Bros (64)
Super Smash Bros Melee
Super Smash Bros Brawl
Super Smash Bros (Wii U or 3DS)

What gave the best performance/most liked/ best delivery in the series?


Around the Network

Super Smash Brothers Melee.

The vastly superior gameplay and the best version of Ganondorf are all reasons I need to be convinced that I have made the right choice. Also love the massive 64-player tournament!

I didn't play enough of anything besides the 64 version to really give it a fair shot. I like the 64 version because it was quite simple and somewhat slow-paced. You could kind of plan out your attacks or counters appropriately.

Brawl. I think Brawl will always be my favorite.

Instead of arguing about who is right or wrong, it is better to understand why each person thinks what they think. 

  Gaming on: PS3, PC, Wii, 3DS(XL), PS Vita, iPhone 4S 

Melee. I played this game like 400 hours with 4 friends over 4 years. I thought the Gamecube was popular >.>

Around the Network

I have all 3 although I love Melee , I have to say I enjoyed Brawl most- online multiplayer helped pushed me to making that decision along with the design of the game, the character list, and all the new additions.

Melee i played over 1mil hours and brawl soon to be!

I like the original, it introduced me to new faces that this day i love (metroid,kirby,f-zero)
I was happy to play fox! I played the original game on SNES!

Brawl has the best gameplay balence IMO. The original just feels dated, but still fun. A bit fast also. Melee just feels and controls weird now after playing Brawl.

I think I've logged over 500 hours playing brawl. The best, and I mean the VERY best offline multiplayer game.

Currently own:


  • Ps3 slim 1 tb (1,000gb) Seagate 2.5 inch SATA
  • PsVITA 32gb 3g/Wifi


Currently playing:


  • PS3: Skyrim (lol again), that's pretty much it.
  • Vita: Sold. Collected to much dust for its own good...


On the Horizon: Getting bored of gaming recently.... Probably taking a break.


I hardly played the series but i liked the one on the nintendo 64

PS3, Vita, 3DS and Wii U. 

PS4 eventually. 

Around the Network
Brawl. I loved the "final smash" moves.

Melee's close, though.