wfz said: Open your door while actively masturbating.
It works like a charm. Not just on religious people, either.
He said they tend to be different groups or people, so you would just continue to have to do it to each new person.
But tough luck. Just have to move I would say. Where i am now, I never have anyone ever come by to do anything but kids selling school stuff. The last place I lived I would get people as often as you said.
Obviously I'm ignoring political campaign time. During that you always get some guy who is running or someone from his family stop by to say hi and drop off a flier, or if not home leave it in the door handle or somethign.