Lost Odyssey
Suikoden 2 without the max peeps (though a few other instances in the game as well)

Final Fantasy VIII when you know who dies

Final Fantasy 8 when Laguna was visiting Raine's grave at the ending and has a memory of when he proposed to her.

it probably still wont have an effect on you because you might be kinda expecting it at this point. If i knew that people cried at that specific part then i probably wouldn't have cried because i would have been expecting it to happen.

I sat there and played it for like 3 days straight until i beat it. I watched every cutscene(OMG the mission briefings)

I was just simply taken advantage of because i didn't see it coming being that i somehow managed to avoid any kind of spoilers before playing it

I also read that the majority of people cried when Big Boss showed up

Only game that really connects with me on an emotional level is Mass Effect 3. It doesn't matter how many times I play the prologue level, but the final cutscene of that level where you flee Earth as it falls to the Reapers hit me quite hard.

Only tears I shed are tears of happiness. No game has yet done that for me.

never cried at any game but recently walking dead ep 3 and 5 pulled at my heartstrings...man was that sad

Well, no. Not really.

I was pretty damn near though at the endings of Super Mario 64 and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time when

Navi left Link... :'(   <-----(Purely symbolic. Never actually shed a tear.)