MrBubbles said:
Rath said:
MrBubbles said:
if not for israel taking those lands there wouldnt even be a chance at a state of palestine. it would still be jordan and egypt. its a small minority in israel that think the entire land should be israel. its a small minority in the territories that dont want the entire land to be palestine. abbas plays lip service to the idea sometimes and then says things that clearly demonstrate he doesnt it. the right of return wont happen and the jews will never give back the western wall in east jerusalem, so those demands cannot be on the table of they want any deal with israel. abbas made recent comments backing off the right of return but they still demand east jerusalem. how can things even get off the ground with an impossible demand?
|
I think if Israel was properly willing to negotiate (which Netanyahu is very much not) with Fatah then I believe the situation could be resolved. Simply however Israel will have to compromise on Jerusalem - the East of Jerusalem is Palestinian and what Israel is trying to do is annex it. This should be condemned.
In any negotiation Israel will have to compromise as well as Palestine, they need to meet in the middle. Your comments seem to indicate that you think Palestine should accept all of Israels demands, this is not reasonable.
|
east jerusalem is not palestinian. what an odd comment from you. how can you even imagine the jews would give up control of their holiest site and give it to someone who they cant even trust? at best you could make an argument for a UN controlled city, but its not like the UN has been able to protect israel from its enemies so far.
there has never even been a state of palestine, mind you.
|
Jerusalem for a large portion of its history has not been Jewish, but majority Muslim. Several of the holiest Muslim sites also exist in Jerusalem.
I think having either state have complete control over the Temple Mount and the adjacent holy sites (Al-Aqsa, Dome of the Rock, Wailing Wall) is a recipe for disaster actually and some sort of communual control over them is required.
However East Jerusalem as a city is largely Muslim in populace and is internationally recognised as not being part of Israel.
Perhaps an international city is a solution to the Jerusalem question, but in my opinion it is either that or the city being divided into two. There simply isn't going to be a long term peace that involves Israel having Jerusalem as its undivided capital.