By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - TOP Console RPG of this Gen: Elimination Game. The Winner is

AndrewWK on 25 May 2012
WiiBox3 said:
AndrewWK said:
Conegamer said:
ethomaz said:
Conegamer said:
As with other threads like this, how people can downvote Xenoblade, regarded by many as the best RPG of the gen, whilst there are still games on the list which aren't even RPG's, is beyond me. I have noted how the people who downvote it, in the majority of cases, don't even have a Wii in the first place, and, as such, can't make a subjective reason why it's the weakest RPG on the list.

It's crazy. These things should have the best RPG's 'til last. That would be Xenoblade, Dark Souls, Disgaea, Radiant Dawn and Valhalla Knights in the final 5. Let's see if that's how things pan out

For me Demon's Souls and Valkyria Chronicles are better than Xenoblade but Xenoblade is a 9.x metascore for sure and one of the best in this gen . Dark Souls lost a lot about what make Demon's Souls so good... Disgaea, Radiant Dawn and Valhalla Knights I didn't play yet.

I never played Demon's Souls, but it does look real good! I've been looking for it on the cheap, but sadly I can't find it...

You should play Valhalla Knights, it's damn good! Of course, Radiant Dawn and Xenoblade are on the Wii which may be why you haven't played them, but both are kings in their RPG genres (Strategy and Japanese) respectively, and as such, deserve to stay until the end.

You can get Demon´s Souls on Amazon for 14 bucks.


He lives in the UK though, but maybe still a good idea if shipping is cheap to the UK.

I meant amazon.co.uk



Around the Network
ethomaz on 25 May 2012

+ Demon's Souls
- Dark Souls



ethomaz on 25 May 2012
AndrewWK said:
WiiBox3 said:

AndrewWK said:

 You can get Demon´s Souls on Amazon for 14 bucks.


He lives in the UK though, but maybe still a good idea if shipping is cheap to the UK.

I meant amazon.co.uk

Please buy the US verison because the server are live yet.

http://www.gameinformer.com/b/news/archive/2012/05/25/demon-39-s-souls-servers-staying-online.aspx



AndrewWK on 25 May 2012
ethomaz said:
AndrewWK said:
WiiBox3 said:

AndrewWK said:

 You can get Demon´s Souls on Amazon for 14 bucks.


He lives in the UK though, but maybe still a good idea if shipping is cheap to the UK.

I meant amazon.co.uk

Please buy the US verison because the server are live yet.

http://www.gameinformer.com/b/news/archive/2012/05/25/demon-39-s-souls-servers-staying-online.aspx

What has Demon´s Souls to do with Atlus?



WiiBox3 on 25 May 2012

+Tales of Vesperia
-Demons Souls



Around the Network
flagstaad on 25 May 2012

+Lost Odyssey
-Yakuza 3



Marteds on 25 May 2012

+ Mass Effect 2
- The Last Story



ethomaz on 25 May 2012
AndrewWK said:

ethomaz said:

Please buy the US verison because the server are live yet.

http://www.gameinformer.com/b/news/archive/2012/05/25/demon-39-s-souls-servers-staying-online.aspx

What has Demon´s Souls to do with Atlus?

Atus is the DS's publisher in US.



Conegamer on 25 May 2012
AndrewWK said:
WiiBox3 said:
AndrewWK said:
Conegamer said:
ethomaz said:
Conegamer said:
As with other threads like this, how people can downvote Xenoblade, regarded by many as the best RPG of the gen, whilst there are still games on the list which aren't even RPG's, is beyond me. I have noted how the people who downvote it, in the majority of cases, don't even have a Wii in the first place, and, as such, can't make a subjective reason why it's the weakest RPG on the list.

It's crazy. These things should have the best RPG's 'til last. That would be Xenoblade, Dark Souls, Disgaea, Radiant Dawn and Valhalla Knights in the final 5. Let's see if that's how things pan out

For me Demon's Souls and Valkyria Chronicles are better than Xenoblade but Xenoblade is a 9.x metascore for sure and one of the best in this gen . Dark Souls lost a lot about what make Demon's Souls so good... Disgaea, Radiant Dawn and Valhalla Knights I didn't play yet.

I never played Demon's Souls, but it does look real good! I've been looking for it on the cheap, but sadly I can't find it...

You should play Valhalla Knights, it's damn good! Of course, Radiant Dawn and Xenoblade are on the Wii which may be why you haven't played them, but both are kings in their RPG genres (Strategy and Japanese) respectively, and as such, deserve to stay until the end.

You can get Demon´s Souls on Amazon for 14 bucks.


He lives in the UK though, but maybe still a good idea if shipping is cheap to the UK.

I meant amazon.co.uk

Yup, just seen it now:

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Namco-Demons-Souls-PS3/dp/B003UBGS1Q/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1337967220&sr=8-1

I has no monies currently (just bought Rayman Origins) but if it's still that price in a few weeks time I'll likely take the plunge!

And the publisher is Namco over here, I think the servers are still up...



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Conegamer on 25 May 2012
pezus said:
Conegamer said:
As with other threads like this, how people can downvote Xenoblade, regarded by many as the best RPG of the gen, whilst there are still games on the list which aren't even RPG's, is beyond me. I have noted how the people who downvote it, in the majority of cases, don't even have a Wii in the first place, and, as such, can't make a subjective reason why it's the weakest RPG on the list.

It's crazy. These things should have the best RPG's 'til last. That would be Xenoblade, Dark Souls, Disgaea, Radiant Dawn and Valkyrie Chronicles in the final 5. Let's see if that's how things pan out

Who are you to say those are the best? Why not Witcher 2...Deus Ex...Mass Effect? RPGs are not just JRPGs

Didn't like Deus Ex, haven't played Witcher 2, and Mass Effect is good, but not as good as the other 5 there. I'd say 2 is the best and would go 7th.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.