Ban-Ish: EA Games Now Playable Offline When Banned

Forums - PC Discussion - Ban-Ish: EA Games Now Playable Offline When Banned

So this is interesting. After we’ve hounded EA for over a year about their bans preventing players from accessing single-player games, and after a year of receiving peculiarly ambiguousstatements, and promises to fix things in time periods that now gather dust, EA has finally (a full year since we first raised the issue with them) partly fixed this issue. Partly. Being banned multiplayer violations will no longer lock you out of your single-player games, and their DLC. Because, it seems, they’ve fixed their Offline mode. But there’s no word on whether forum violations can still affect gaming access.


We never did receive an official explanation as to why this was happening in the first place. In March 2011 the impression given was that it was an error that needed to be fixed. Despite this, moderators and EA Support staff continued to maintain that it was deliberate, and very many of our readers got in touch to explain that they too were banned from their games, a worrying number of whom had done nothing that could constitute a violation in the first place. This got worse again toward the end of last year, and since then – despite repeated attempts – we heard nothing more from EA on the matter.

However, anonymously we heard all sorts, from some extremely reliable sources, that led us to believe that one end of EA really had no idea what the other end was doing, and fixing the issue – which does seem to be their goal – is far more complicated than you’d imagine. Whatever the reason, however deliberate the bans were, and however elaborate sorting it may have been, they have publicly declared that no longer will it happen. And this is extremely good news, to an extent. You simply go offline.

Oddly, this hasn’t suddenly been fixed now. The terms were updated on the 8th March, but they’ve only alerted people to it now. The cynical will assume that this might be an attempt to garner good press in light of their being the Worst Company In America. Unfortunately, there are still concerning matters…

Bad news is, this doesn’t cover the matter of whether forum violations will still constitute multiplayer gaming bans. Because while being locked out of your single player games and DLC was undoubtedly massively wrong, and possibly in violation of all manner of consumer law, being banned from a multiplayer game because you said “e-peen” (or any number of other innocuous offenses, or even without any meaningful reason at all) on an unrelated forum is bewildering, and ridiculous. And has to stop.

We’ll contact EA about this first thing tomorrow, and find if there is to be any progress on this matter as well. Half way there? You can follow the whole saga via this tag.

Cheers, Gaming Blend.


@TheVoxelman on twitter

Check out my hype threads: Cyberpunk, and The Witcher 3!

Around the Network
You'd be surprised at how piss-poor intra-company communications are in many places. My college of choice (Saint Joseph's University), is fairly small, but so many of the departments are completely clueless about policies of other departments, even when those policies are very relevant to the doings of their department.

Not that i'm excusing anything, of course, but such egregious errors are more common than people might think simply because of intra-company jurisdictional issues. Likely here they just imposed a uniform ban system that worked all across your Origin login (which i'm assuming is required even to access offline games), so that a few flames on the forums would suddenly lead to a lockout from Dead Space 2's story mode, and then this login system was such a simple system that differentiating between things (e.g. your ability to log in for offline and DLC) was a lot of work.

Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

A rare good move from EA. Let's celebrate this for what it is, and not get our hopes up for too much more of the same in future.

To those thinking this is just a move to save face: so what? Either way, the functionality is added. It's just good that we've been able to motivate them.

(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

gamrReview - Arthur Kabrick | My All-Time Top 50 | 2013 Metascores