By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Wii Review Channel

That really is quite a fantastic idea (although fortunately the video Yuk04 pointed shows they might already be on the right way). If you wan't to mail them about this you can count me in.



Wii Number: 6834 4776 2070 3061

Cute, aren't they? More in my profile (I made them, lol)
Around the Network

"The rating system should also require you to register the game or at least have played it before being able to rate it. By registering the game, your rating of it would have more weight, but it would require you to punch in the pin number that comes in the box."

What pin number? :-s I've never got one in a game.



viva españa!



spain is the best country!!!!!



ferret1603 said:
"The rating system should also require you to register the game or at least have played it before being able to rate it. By registering the game, your rating of it would have more weight, but it would require you to punch in the pin number that comes in the box."

What pin number? :-s I've never got one in a game

That may only be nintendo games that get that insert, but 3rd party games could use the UPC code or something. Usually it's thrown in with all that advertizment paper you get, it'll be a white piece of paper with a blue square surrounding a string of alphanumeric characters that you can use to register teh game on nintendo.com.

Oh, and part of the reason I'm asking other people to write in is I figure of 12 - 100 people write in saying it's a good idea, it might work better than if just one person mentions it 



Seppukuties is like LBP Lite, on crack. Play it already!

Currently wrapped up in: Half Life, Portal, and User Created Source Mods
Games I want: (Wii)Mario Kart, Okami, Bully, Conduit,  No More Heroes 2 (GC) Eternal Darkness, Killer7, (PS2) Ico, God of War1&2, Legacy of Kain: SR2&Defiance


My Prediction: Wii will be achieve 48% market share by the end of 2008, and will achieve 50% by the end of june of 09. Prediction Failed.

<- Click to see more of her

 

Around the Network

Everyone's Nintendo Channel is the answer. Wii owners would watched movies or play a demo of the game.



yeah....so many wii channels, about wheather, news and news.....but not a single one for Wii or at least nintendo news!!! i hope the everyone channel is something......also more preview channels like the MP3 one.... :)



Wii console: 0595 8808 5698 2709
Super Smash Bros Brawl: 1161 1357 5188

Mario Kart Wii: 1633 4506 4319

PES 2008: 1633 5820 0347

DragonBall Z BT 3: 3823 9760 9484

Pokemon Battle Revolution: 3480 2645 9186
Feel free to add me, and sent me a pm with your Friend Code!!

 

Grey Acumen said:
ferret1603 said:
"The rating system should also require you to register the game or at least have played it before being able to rate it. By registering the game, your rating of it would have more weight, but it would require you to punch in the pin number that comes in the box."

What pin number? :-s I've never got one in a game

That may only be nintendo games that get that insert, but 3rd party games could use the UPC code or something. Usually it's thrown in with all that advertizment paper you get, it'll be a white piece of paper with a blue square surrounding a string of alphanumeric characters that you can use to register teh game on nintendo.com.

Oh, and part of the reason I'm asking other people to write in is I figure of 12 - 100 people write in saying it's a good idea, it might work better than if just one person mentions it

 

Maybe it's just in the US. I always look at the inserts and I've definitely never got anything matching that description. I just get the manual and the standard black technical insert.



When I first started reading the topic I thought it was talking about the Everyone Channel. The ability to have each Wii owner review games and have those reviews acessable from the Wii is an awesome idea. Obviously 3rd parties would have the option to include PIN codes with their games for weighted reviews, but it would not be necessary. Using the UPC codes would be too easy to exploit (each box of SMG has the same UPC after all.)

Honestly the Nintendo would be genius to implement it with weighted averages for people who not just played the game on their Wii but submit a PIN proving they own it: Want your review to really count then buy the game! HEH HEH HEH!

I do not see anyway to really cheat the system if it only counts reviews from people who score games the way you do. If you are allowing each Mii to submit a review instead of just once per system people could make a trash Mii to hurt reviews of certain games. Yet, if it checks the play history on the Wii to make sure you've played the game before allowing a review to be submitted, and gives more clout to owners then sales likely won't see much of a negative impact from trolls.

I only have one question: My aunt buys a Wii and only owns Wii Sports, how will it show her reviews if she has yet to submit a review for Sports, and even after that is only one game so I immagine lots of people who have very different tastes in games could all rate Sports an 'A'. How would that be delt with?



Grey Acumen said:
DMeisterJ said:
Or, you could use the user review section of any good gaming website (Gamespot... no wait, scratch that; IGN, etc.)

You could, i could, but we're talking about the most casual of Wii owners, the ones who apparenlty think games like Chicken shoot and ninja breadman are worth purchasing, simply because they're cheap. These people are teh same ones naysayers are going on about ruining the industry. you can't just boot them out, you have to educate them, and you have to do it in a way that gets that education out TO them. A Wii channel specifically for reviewing games this way would ensure that they had a good game list right at their fingertips.

Lets face that, you already said "or any good gaming website, Gamespot, no scratch that."

Even if it's a joke, it still demonstrates the basic concept of the problems with finding a "GOOD" game review website. Even if it is a good game, there's still teh issue of the basic differences in what a casual gamer wants vs what a more hardcore gamer wants.

Yuk04 said:
I think that they were talking about something like, you play a game, and you give you're age so another gamers could see the average age of the user of that game.

also I think that they were talking about showing which games have been played the longest hours on the Wii, so people could see the most played games on the system.
See, this still holds the problem in that not all 8 year olds like the same games, not all 24 year olds want Manhunt 2, etc. Just because people play wii sports 24 hours a day because that's the only game they've got doesn't mean that's the game everyone wants to keep playing. That's why I'm talking about having the rating system represent games that other people with similarly rated games enjoy. That way your PERSONAL preference is what you will see put towards the top of the list. Not just an age bracket.

 

 


You my friend are correct, I'd not want to push Ninjabread Man on anyone.  :(