pezus said: yo_john117 said: pezus said: yo_john117 said: pezus said: yo_john117 said: Haven't played this game so I can't give a score but hopefully one day I'll get a chance to finish the second one and play UC3. Also it appears you are having problems with the table as well (sure is a bitch!) It currently looks like my prediction is doing well so far :D Well I'll give you one thing...it's closer than I thought it would be. I still think that it will just barely edge out to a 9 though. Hmmm, we need more reviews Really? I count more than 10 reviews. No, I just meant that it'd be good to have more reviews in.

Ah ok. Yeah pretty much every game in the ranking game threads could do with more reviews.

Well, in my games collection I have it rated as a 9.3, which is, on my rating scale, a notch below FFXIII and a notch above Red Dead Redemption, which is a very good score. When I look back at the game though, it does have some glaring issues, so I've been considering bumping down the score. Also, my ratings are too bunched up near the top end and need spacing out. When I've changed and readjusted everything, I think Uncharted 3's score will come out at a 8.9/10, so put me down for that.

Uncharted 3 was a great game, but it had its issues. It didn't feel as fresh as the first two, it had poor pacing, it abandoned all story development about halfway through and wasted a lot of potential and it started to get repetitive after a while.

Still, it is the best looking game this generation, it had some epic moments, especially the plane and desert section, holy shit, it was a fun ride and the characters were hilarious.

So yeah, 8.9/10, GOTY for me.

I suggest Batman Arkham City or Gears of War 3

8.5 my score might change when I actually play the game

10/10

while Uncharted has never been one of my favorite franchises, Uncharted 3 just really drew me in.
i would give Uncharted DF- 8.3, Uncharted AT- 8.9, and Uncharted DD- 9.9.

its graphics are just phenominal, the best i have ever seen, better than even Cyrsis 2. from drake interacting to wall, to a cruise line toppling over in real time. its a looker.

the gunplay is awesome, you can shoot and throw grenades from an position, rolling, jumping, climbing. its great.

Story is great to, you really learn what motivates Nate through these journeys and why he does it, and it really expounds on his and sully's friendship.

Multiplayer is awesome, i love the co-op. its like a mini story line.

edit

8.5/10 Great game. 2 full playthroughs never got boring.
The story was a bit less focussed then Uncharted 2, and there weren't as many wow moments in the first half of the game.

9/10 Best PS3 Exclusive of 2011. It was fantastic, but it didn't have the flare that Uncharted 2 had. That's because U2 was just a big step up, so nothing to be ashamed of. Can't wait for U4.

Please don't count in his score... 

Well now I have played enough to give it a score, (6 hours SP, 3.5 hours MP)

Lets start with the positives
+ The bromance between Drake and Sully
+ Water looks even better this time around (the physics I'm not attracted to liquids...)
+ It follows the strengths of what the uncharted games have done...

Cons
- Many things feel out of place story wise (They could of avoided the boat scene level but they just wanted one so they had to make the story line somehow work around that..)
- Loses alot of it's flair because it's the sequel to UC2 (Doesn't have such a fresh feeling to it)
- Shooting and stealth aspects still feel weak.

(Score edit reason: After playing some more again at friends it's hard to give it that score when the shooting is that weak and big part of gameplay...)

Overall 8.0 Compared to UC2 which I would give a 8.9.