Quantcast
The VGChartz Ranking Game -- Uncharted 3 -- Results!

Forums - Gaming Discussion - The VGChartz Ranking Game -- Uncharted 3 -- Results!

Tagged games:

Uncharted 3 is...

the best game EVER! 30 17.75%
 
the best game of 2011! 40 23.67%
 
the best PS3 game of 2011! 20 11.83%
 
the best PS3 exclusive of 2011! 19 11.24%
 
a great game! 13 7.69%
 
a good game.. 11 6.51%
 
worth a rental..? 5 2.96%
 
a game with some hard flaws to overlook. 12 7.10%
 
a bad game! 16 9.47%
 
a deception! 3 1.78%
 
Total:169

*Insert Funny*

All you have to do is put what score you think the game below deserves, and write a brief explanation as to why it deserves that score, hell you can even just write your opinion of the game and not add a score if you want to (which we won't add to the total of course)

Voting is open for a 1 week period, after 1 week I will count up all the scores and get the average of the game. 

Rules

1. You had to have played at least enough of the game to form an honest opinion about it

2. If you score a game over or under 4 points of what it's at on Metacritic you must go into great detail for your review.

3. If you put more than 1 score per thread none of your scores will be counted.

4. A game must have at least 10 people that gave it a score to be counted.

5. Users with less than 50 posts cannot participate unless they have been a member on this site for more than a year.

Last game was The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim and it got 8.06

Highest score was 10, lowest was 1

Vgchartz score -- 8.99 / GamrReview score -- 9.0 / Metacritic score -- 92

VGChartz Top 15

Game Score
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 9.65
Super Mario Galaxy 2 9.5
Super Mario Galaxy 9.49
Metal Gear Solid 4 9.36
The Orange Box 9.35
LittleBigPlanet 2 9.34
Starcraft 2: Wings of Liberty 9.27
Halo Reach 9.23
Donkey Kong Country Returns 9.23
Monster Hunter Tri 9.19
Gears of War 2 9.17
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess 9.18
Halo 3 9.13
Super Smash Bros. Brawl 9.13
Mass Effect 2 9.12

Next game: TBD; Drop a suggestion!

To view a list of all games from every game ranking thread click here.

Thanks to Blacksaber for the awesome ranking game logo and thanks to everyone who participate(s/d).



Around the Network

Haven't played this game so I can't give a score but hopefully one day I'll get a chance to finish the second one and play UC3.

Also it appears you are having problems with the table as well (sure is a bitch!)



yo_john117 said:
Haven't played this game so I can't give a score but hopefully one day I'll get a chance to finish the second one and play UC3.

Also it appears you are having problems with the table as well (sure is a bitch!)

It's weird because I had it working fine last week when you asked. I did just copy the HTML of your last OP so there might be some problem with the surrounding HTML that is screwing things up. It's going to be a mess to go through. *sigh*



trasharmdsister12 said:
yo_john117 said:
Haven't played this game so I can't give a score but hopefully one day I'll get a chance to finish the second one and play UC3.

Also it appears you are having problems with the table as well (sure is a bitch!)

It's weird because I had it working fine last week when you asked. I did just copy the HTML of your last OP so there might be some problem with the surrounding HTML that is screwing things up. It's going to be a mess to go through. *sigh*

Yeah everytime I get it centered whilst editing it will end up going to the side no matter what when I posted it. That's why I ended up just making it go accross the whole thing like the last thread.

Of course I could try to make a picture with the top 15 in it, that might work.



Ah, Uncharted 3. What a great game.

Naughty Dog tries so hard to raise the bar of storytelling in video games, but then games come out that are just fun to play and reviewers call their stories amazing. That surely must be a bit disheartening for the developers of the Uncharted series. But oh well, that's life. Deal with it.

I give Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception a score of 9.0/10, because I haven't played it.



Legend11 correctly predicted that GTA IV (360+PS3) would outsell SSBB. I was wrong.

A Biased Review Reloaded / Open Your Eyes / Switch Gamers Club

Around the Network

I rated it 9.5/10 in my Game Collection so I think I'll just stick to that score. For me, Uncharted 3 was an improvement over UC2 in many ways and its equal in all other areas. Graphics are unmatched on the PS3, its cinematic storytelling as well. It felt like I was playing an exciting movie and that's the way I like it.



Tough one to rate, the single player is inferior to UC2, but the multiplayer somewhat improved.

Single player:
- Story not as good as UC2
- Plot holes, lots of them
- Anti-climax ending, just repeats UC2 ending and the 'secret treasure' never really sees the light of day and gets sunk.
- Animations on enemies non existent for much of the game, shoot them and get no reaction unti they die.
- Some levels just felt like filler (ship graveyard etc)
- No cheats to unlock for fun like UC1 and 2 had
- Had aiming issues on release
- Checkpoint system blows when trying to stealth areas.
- Quite a number of bugs


Multiplayer:
+ Upped health from UC2, game less campy now
+ Customisation of characters
+ Custom loadouts
+ Added kickbacks
+ Some good size larger maps
+ Co-op adventure is better then UC2
+ Removed quit penalty
- Game still suffers from nade spam.
- They tweaking the game in tiny pieces towards UC2 style
- Customisation blows compared to beta
- Characters models godawful
- Character animations not as alive as UC2
- Still get laggy players given an advantage
- Matchmaking still blows
- Weapon balance blows
- Kickback balance blows
- Booster balance blows
- Reusing UC2 maps not only for game on release but also for map packs
- The Euro FHC is way more expensive than US one with the offer they gave it.
- Trying to play alone almost always puts you in an already started game
- Various matchmaking bugs
- Non adventure/Hunter co-op is worse than UC2, combines all modes and most people dislike siege and treasure carry
- Co-op Hunter is poorly thought out.
- Treasure system for unlocks really sucks forcing people to play modes they may not like and in the case of Hardcore and co-op the drop rate is just so low you could be forced to play for dozens of hours on each mode for those unlocks.

Overall the game feels rushed and unfinished, missing features, reusing so much from UC2, still a great game though overall.

9.



________________________________________________________________

8.9/10 Uncharted 3

Not the best of the trilogy gamewise but Storywise...awesome!!! Loved it!



PS One/2/p/3slim/Vita owner. I survived the Apocalyps3/Collaps3 and all I got was this lousy signature.


Xbox One: What are you doing Dave?

hmm havent seen these threads

im defiantly qualified to review the game though, i was the one with the UC2 2M sales before 09 ended was very hyped for that game after playing DF saying that i was let down would be an understatement, just didnt like the direction they went with it. i did enjoy its MP have about 40 days of play time on i liked its balance and every single map

now UC3 though its SP over all experience was a bit better than AT but still behind DF my main issues are very slow start, lack of gunplay and difficulty that we've seen in DF but just slight better than AT in that department. im not feeling the whole cinematic gameplay theres no challenge, very little thought process and doesnt do well for replay value. the whole elena and drake relationship just makes me want to puke ND should of went hardcore of killed off elena when they had the chance in AT just let drake do his own thing. game had a few more bugs than the past two and the graphics where a little bit of a mixed bag the AA seem worse than AT

on to the MP although i hated it in the beginning im starting to like things now, i like split screen (although a little late most games in this genre had this since 06) i have to give em credit for adding it, i also like the treasure system and customization. i dont think though that i will put as much time in it as i did with ATs i really cant put my finger on it but feel its kinda like the whole COD thing you know where everyone likes MW1 MP over every one that came after it.

i think this is b/c the game play experience that we saw in UC2 and MW1 MP was new and fresh for that time, as well with the maps the very basic smaller yet satisfying maps found in these 2 games compared to there predecessors would keep the majority of the community coming back. i also dont like the gun loadouts i really liked how ATs MP was where every one just starts with a pistol and ak it felt more balanced and less COD and also the maps some are hard on the eyes and to complicated like highrise and city of brass

overall i really feel like the uncharted series is one of the most overrated series out there i wouldnt give niether one anything over a 9. i dont feel like people who are missing out on the games are really missing out on anything story and gameplay wise, there good games but it gets on my nerves when you here people in the gaming industry like sessler say AT was the greatest SP game in the last 10 yrs and all these other comments similar to that. what about games like the original MGS, halflife, bioshock, silent hill 2, max payne, ect

overall id give a 8.4



                                                             

                                                                      Play Me

9.2/10

Very great. But it didn't have that spark U2 had.