+dead space
-zelda SS

WTF stupid hater eliminating Uncharted 3 and Gears of War 3. And how the hell is DC2 above UC3!

Millenium said:
+ Crysis 2
-... Uncharted 3

Millenium said:
+ Batman
- Fifa 12 (dead)

So you have 3 - votes next time. (You voted +/- for the same game 3 times, just once before it got eliminated, so I told you the wrong number - votes last time)

SvennoJ said:
+ Ico / SotC collection
- Crysis 2

I told you the wrong number of -'ve you have, You have one extra for this vote (you made a different Portal/Crysis vote before which I counted with your last edit)

pezus said:
+Uncharted 3   +Shogun 2
-Modern Combat 3: Fallen Nation

Only needed 1 vote to kill Modern Combat. You have 2 -'ives, will count this Shogun vote when you do that (you can still + Shogun and give it two votes)

osamanobama said: x3
+Uncharted
-zelda SS

Same here, you just missed it. The -'ve before you two killed UC3. You have four +'ves next vote

melbye said:
+Skyward Sword
-Forza Motorsport 4

Forza died a long time ago, you have two -'ves on your next vote.

The_Botman said:

+ Uncharted
- Skyward Sword

yo_john117 said: x3
+ DCS: A-10C Warthog
- Uncharted 3

Rainbow Yoshi said:
+Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception
- Portal 2

Aldro said:
+Uncharted 3
-Skyward Sword

Xxain said:
+ Skyward Sword
- Uncharted 3

Scoobes said:
+ Deus Ex: Human Revolution
- Uncharted 3

Light Yagami said:
+ Metal Gear Solid HD
- Uncharted 3

Lodder said:
+ Uncharted 3
- Skyward Sword

Mirson said:
+ Batman: Arkham City
- Uncharted 3

dsage01 said:
+Uncharted 3
-Zelda SS

zarx said: x2

+The Witcher
-Uncharted 3

turtuls said:
+ minecraft
- Uncharted 3

You all missed Uncharted by 1 vote. So much support, if only it was 1 vote ahead of where it was before it was eliminated. Sorry guys, 1 vote and look how many +'s (no negatives for a long stretch) since that eliminating vote.

Jay520 said:
I don't know why you people are voting down Uncharted 3. Uncharted 3 WILL win this thread. Nothing's going to change that. Voting it down will just be a waste of your votes.

.........Well.......If that were the case I wouldn't have quoted 30 people now....

worldlyfall said:
+ Skyward Sword
- Uncharted 3

And you were the one to kill it. Still eliminated. you have 2 -'ve votes.

EVERYONE you all voted Uncharted 3 after it was eliminated. You must all make a new vote with the appropriate number of +'ve and -'ves. If you're listed above, and you + voted it, then you have two (or more) + votes next time and they must be different games. If you -'ve voted it, then you have two (or more) - votes next time and they must be different games.

chocoloco said:

I do not hate uncharted 3 at all, but it is the worst game on this list of games.  

+Dance Central 2
- Skyward sword

chocoloco said:
Michael-5 is going to have fun with this thread counting up all the votes when he gets up. (just have to quote 9/10 people)

+Dance Central 2
- Deus Ex

Dance Central is dead, you have 3 + votes next turn

thehusbo said:
+uncharted 3
-forza 4

Both are dead..

SnakeDrake said:
+Dark Souls
-Crysis 2

Crysis gone

------

From before: (Didn't see these two post since)

Unfortunatly, Skyrim was eliminated. You get 2 + votes next times, then I'll count this vote.

rakugakist said:
Plus skyrim
minus skyward sword.

Skyrim is out, you get two + votes next time

Bman54 said:
+Skyward Sword
-Skyrim

Skyrim is out, you get two - votes next time

Mass Effect 2 isn't a port, it's a remake. Mass Effect 2 on PS3 uses the ME3 engine, it's the same game, but on a different engine. Also ME2 is probably the best game made last year.

Forza 4 is arguably the best racing sim this gen (It's the funnest at least as told by it's strong review scores).

Skyrim is only buggy on PS3, I've played it on PC and 360 and have not run into anywhere nearly as many bugs. It's a AAA game, when you make a game with an overworld that expansive, there will be some bugs. Didn't deserve to die.

What about Gears of War 3? That's one of the best games this year, and it has great multiplayer.

Too much hate all over, and to be fair, if UC3 was 1 + vote ahead at that critical time, it would still be near the top. It got lots of + votes after, enough to keep it alive.

I'm out during the day, so sometimes my updates will be 12 hours apart. It's hard to keep up, I mean who could have guessed that Uncharted had been eliminated?

For the edit rule, you have to vote different games (solves your power issue).

Also I don't mind, most people seem to understand the rule and are editing appropriatly.

Haha, I have to do so many edits I'm getting confused, so next time 1+ and 3 -?

Sorry pezus, don't go jackie chan on us!

I'm not saying Sony shouldn't have made the game, I'm saying I can't support voting for it because I should still be able to play my DVD copies on my PS3.

I don't think BC is an extra, it's a basic inclusion. How hard would it be to have PS3 emulate PS2 disks? That price was ridiculous at the start, but if BC is so important, why don't they include BC support intheir higher memory models? I'd pay the extra for that.

Also I probably will get it when I get a PS4 (Ps3 broke, waiting for the gen to end to replace it with a BC PS4). I don't have ICO, but I could always borrow the PS2 disk....which I can't play now.

You had 4 +'s, but other people down voted Modern Combat, so 2 of your valid downvotes for MC turned into 1 valid vote. So you need to correct for that before I can count Shogun (which corrects for an Uncharted 3 vote).

You vote two down and 1 up next time, and when you do I will also count Shogun from above. You got it.

I have to agree with this. I get to watch my girlfriend shake her ass in Dance Central 2. As fun as Uncharted 3 is, booty >>.....well digital booty (Drakes treasure and digital booty).