great a game that is unplayable on my ps3 wins GOTY! of course uncharted 3 wasnt gonna win because it had to live up to uncharted 2 and ppl were expecting so much. also take into account thats its difficult for an exclusive title to win against multi platform games. ill tell you right now if another batman game comes out by rocksteady they are gonna have so much pressure on them because of arkham city and everyone will be disappointed and rage. what a joke.

Claymore, another PS3 freak

That's why I suggest Bethesda stop making PS3 games and get back to morrowind era (PC focused + Xbox), good old days

PS3 freak will overstate the bugs and won't like Bethesda's games like we did (from Daggerfall to Fallout 3, then Skyrim)

All PS3 gamers want are those cinematic exprience, nothing all... They won't appreciate open-world RPGs,

PS3 owners do have a reason to complain about Skyrim and Bethesda. The lag bug is completely game-breaking after sometime (I know I wouldn't play Skyrim on my PC if it hit single digits FPS, much less stay that way for minutes at a time). 

Bethesda screwed up the PS3 version and gamers have the right to be pissed at them. That being said, they don't have the right to belittle all the versions of the game just because they can't play it. Doing that, they lose all argumentative reasons.

How can you know if the PS3 gamers are overreacting,if you've only played the PC and 360 version?Try to make some goddamn sense.

I don't know how bad Skyrim's bugs are but I will say this: Games should be judged based on the entire experience it offers in a wholistic view. Not as a combination of individual aspects.

Lets take Shadow of the Collossus for example. The game had it's fair share of technical issues, but that does not detract from it being one of my most beloved games of all times. When I give the game a 10/10, that doesn't mean it does every individual aspect better than every other game. No, a 10/10 means that, as a complete and whole package, the game offers an overall experience unmatched by any other game.

That's how I think people feel about Skyrim. Sure the game has faults, but the game's pros must be great enough to still give the player an experience that trumps nearly every other game.

Of course, if the game has game-breaking bugs, then none of what I said applies here.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ljQMpgVY5mg&feature=related

The biggest, and with some of the least credibility

I wasn't aware you played Skyrim on the PS3.