Only voting for categories where I have played games...
Best RPG:
Dark Souls(1), Mass Effect 2(2), The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim(3), Dragon Age II(4), Dungeon Siege III(5)
Best First Person Shooter:
Killzone 3(1), Resistance 3(2)
Best Third Person Shooter:
Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception(1), Dead Space 2(2), Warhammer 40k: Space MArine(3), Resident Evil 4 HD(4)
Best Action/Adventure:
Batman: Arkham City(1), Assassin's Creed: Revelations(2), inFamous 2(3)
Best Puzzle Game:
Catherine(1)
Best PSN Download:
Dungeon Defenders(1), Might and Magic: Clash of Heroes(2), Resident Evil 4 HD(3)
Best New IP:
Dungeon Defenders(1), Catherine(2)
Best remake/collection:
Resident Evil 4 HD(1)
Best Graphics :
Uncharted 3(1), AC Revelations (2), Skyrim (3)
Best Original Music Score :
Uncharted 3(1), Skyrim (2)
Most Innovative :
Dungeon Defenders (1), Catherine (2)
Biggest Disappointment :
AC Revelations (1), Uncharted 3(2)
Best Game No One Played :
Warhammer 40k: Space Marine(1), Two Worlds 2 (2), Dungeon Defenders (3)
Most Anticipated Game :
Mass Effect 3(1), GTA V (2), Borderlands 2 (3), Kingdom of Amalur: reckoning (4),
PS3 Game of the Year :
Dark Souls (1), Mass Effect 2(2), Skyrim (3),Uncharted 3(4), Batman Arkham City (5)
Uncharted 3 makes both my best game of the year and disapointment vote as the game is good but I still feel it's a step back compared to Uncharted 2 and could have been a lot better ( the plane level was much hyped but was a big letdown compared to what the train level was in Uncharted 2 for example).
As for AC Revelations well, 1 release/year is just too much, at least Brotherhood added a kick ass MP but Revelations just doesn't have enough new stuff...
