By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - 2011: Top 10 games thus far (META SCORES) [UPDATED: Uncharted3 92; Skryim 96; Zelda 95]

ImJustBayuum said:

  

**Reviews still in progress, position may change

- Excludes: re-releases, handheld releases, online releases (ie psn, xbla..etc)

The PS3 version of Batman AC is rated higher at 96..



Around the Network

Not fair to count Zelda, even if I'm predicting a 96.



I wonder what Xenoblades would be rated if the shitty US video game media got a hold of it.



The_Joker_Product said:
RolStoppable said:
The_Joker_Product said:
How typical Zelda gets a high score, no different from Mario always getting those kind of scores even though theyre obviously no match for HD games.

That's exactly why Zelda and Mario get better scores, because they are in a different league. A higher one.

Yeah i dont think so.

Sorry to barge in like this but that sure is a disappointing response. You started off with a brilliant post which was full of potential. Rol took the bait, and I expected something amazing what with you having a Joker avatar and all.

You just killed all the fun with that lame response. Please reconsider editing your post, quickly, before Rol finds out.



Xenoblade was on 93 for AAAAAAAAAGES. And now it's gone down

Still, 92 is awesome, and I expect SS to get 96-99 when all is said and done.

All those people who doubt this- play the damn game first.

 

Also, quick note- It's the Elder Scrolls:Skyrim, not Oblivion: Skyrim



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Around the Network

oblivion: Skyrim? LOL



skyward sword could very well go down to below 95. There are far too few reviews to reach a conclusion, especially considering its already gotten a 90, so its evidently not a work from god that all reviewers will consider perfect. 

Personally I think the list will end like this at the end of the year. For multiplatform games my scores are ordered 360/PS3/PC. OFC skyrim score could be way off since we don't even have one review score to start gaging critical opinion. 

1. Portal 95/95/95 - 95avg

2. Skyrim 95/93/95 - 94.67avg

3. Skyward Sword 94

4. Batman 95/96/90 - 93.67 avg

5. Uncharted  93

6. Rayman 90/94/94 - 92.67avg  Third score is wii instead of  PC

7. LittlebigPlanet 2 92 

8. Xenoblade Chronicles 91

9. Forza 4 91

10. Gears of War 3 91



The_Joker_Product said:
How typical Zelda gets a high score, no different from Mario always getting those kind of scores even though theyre obviously no match for HD games.


No.



Chrizum said:
The_Joker_Product said:
RolStoppable said:
The_Joker_Product said:
How typical Zelda gets a high score, no different from Mario always getting those kind of scores even though theyre obviously no match for HD games.

That's exactly why Zelda and Mario get better scores, because they are in a different league. A higher one.

Yeah i dont think so.

Sorry to barge in like this but that sure is a disappointing response. You started off with a brilliant post which was full of potential. Rol took the bait, and I expected something amazing what with you having a Joker avatar and all.

You just killed all the fun with that lame response. Please reconsider editing your post, quickly, before Rol finds out.

:lol I almost took the bait. 



3DS Friend Code:   4596-9822-6909

Arkham City ( PS3 ) sits at 96,not 95.