By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Which game will sell better, Skyrim(360) or Uncharted 3, First Week? After 1 Year?

 

Will I be accurate?

Division doesn't lie. Th... 37 26.62%
 
Stupid threadstarter, you... 41 29.50%
 
Math is fake so you are wrong! 28 20.14%
 
I only read the beginning but your right! 18 12.95%
 
I only read the beginning but your wrong! 14 10.07%
 
Total:138

Well I was bored and cranky waiting for one of my classes to start so I decided to find out! Using the magical tool of division and a bunch of data from Vgchartz this is what "should" be the first week and 1 year total sales.

Skyrim will sell 1.55 mil first week + or - 100k

Uncharted 3 will sell 1.35mil first week + or - 100k (First week sales go to skyrim)

After 1 year both will be around 5mil + or - 500k     (1 year total sales will be tied)

For those who care this is how I found these numbers. I explain the numbers in the first table. But the rest of the tables follow the same guidelines.

Fallout New Vegas

4 weeks to go preorders 362385 (68.95% of preorders)
last week of preorders 525556 (81.36% of first week sales)
launch week in usa 645971 (74.71% of WW Sales)
launch week total 864595 (30.86% of 1year sales)
1 year total 2801446 

using the same percents

Elder Scrolls V Skyrim

4 weeks to go preorder 698614
PREDICTION LAST week preorder 1013218
PREDICTED LAUNCH WEEK IN USA 1245351
PREDICTED WW WEEK 1 1666913
PREDICTED 1 YEAR TOTAL 5401534

Shortcoming with this prediction. Oblivion actually outsold fallout 3 in EMEAA so Elder scrolls might be a bigger franchise than Fallout in EMEAA which these percentages don't take account.

Fallout New Vegas had 5 days to sell its first week in America and 2 days in EMEAA. Skyrim will have 2 days to sell in both America and EMEAA.

Japan sales are not going to increase by the same percentage as America and EMEAA.

Games with bigger openings have a much harder time keeping the ratio of their legs to opening week the same as games withlower openings. 

With this facts into consideration.

I think skyrim's first week will be 1.55mil which should be very accurate. 

It will have a much better week 2 ratio wise than Fallout New Vegas though, since its week one was so few days.

and 1 year 5mil which won't be too accurate as year long sales of a game depend on many factors.

Uncharted 2

3 weeks till launch 107360 (56.84%)
last week of preorders 188882 (45.25%)
First week of sales USA 417463 (49.11%)
Firt week of Sales WW 850023 (22.85%)
1 year total Sales 3720000

Uncharted 3 

3 weeks till launch 306407
PREDICTION LAST week preorder 539069
PREDICTED LAUNCH WEEK IN USA 1191313
PREDICTED WW WEEK 1 2435806
PREDICTED 1 YEAR TOTAL 10616219

Shortcomings with predictions. There is no way Uncharted 3's preorders will be able to increase by the same percent in the last week as uncharted 2. Uncharted 2 only needed 40k weekly preorders.Uncharted 3 would need over 100k weekly preorders.

The preorder to first week ratio is probably going to be a bit lower. People were suprised when Uncharted 2 recieved so much critical acclaim. This time they won't be so its reasonable a bigger percentage will preorder the game.

Uncharted 2 was not a well established franchise It would be more to compare the percent increases of Uncharted 3 with with God of War 3 to get America first week sales and than use the Uncharted 2 ratios to find the first week sales WW and over 1 year.

We get this when we take those percents.

God of War 3

3 weeks till launch  405802 (83.33%)
Last week of preorders 486992 (59.85%)
First week in Americas 813742 


Uncharted 3 will obviously do better in EMEAA then God of War 3 did, so I'll use the uncharted 2 percentages to find first week WW and 1 year total.

Uncharted 3 

3 weeks till launch  306407
Last week of preorders 367703
First week in Americas 614374
First Week WW with Uncharted 2 % 1251017
1 year total with Uncharted 2 % 5474910

Shortcomings with this prediction is Japan numbers will be way too high since it won't increase by the same percent

Games with bigger openings have a much harder time keeping the ratio of their legs to opening week the same as games with lower openings. 

Uncharted 2 only had 2 day to sell in EMEAA and had 5 days to sell in America. Uncharted 3 will have 4 days to sell in EMEAA and 5 days to sell in America for its first week.

Realistaclly its first week should be around 1.35mil which should be very accurate.

Its sales will drop more substantially week 2 as it had a lot of days to sell week one unlike Uncharted 2 in EMEAA.

But its 1 year total should be around 5mil which won't be too accurate as year long sales of a game depend on many factors.



Around the Network

Odd match-up but like you say, Skyrim wins first week, Uncharted 3 might win lifetime.

Skyrim 5 million on X360, Uncharted 3 around 5 million.



Whats the point of not including the ps3 version its the same game so Skyrim will blow by Uncharted 3. If your going to compare sales at least do it to another game that is exclusive. For Example Gears of War 3 1st week vs UC3 1st week.



First week - Skyrim 360

Lifetime - Uncharted 3 PS3



No way that Skyrim will sell 5 million on just xbox360 after one year!!!



http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=130023&page=1# Official Playstation Vita Thread! Come in and join!!!

Around the Network

skyrim i believe will win 1st week and lifetime. but lifetime sales should be very close.



GAMERTAG IS ANIMEHEAVEN X23

PSN ID IS : ANIMEREALM 

PROUD MEMBER OF THE RPG FAN CLUB THREAD

ALL-TIME FAVORITE JRPG IS : LOST ODYSSEY

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=52882&page=1

Uncharted 3 first week.
Uncharted 3 lifetime.



 

 

 

Skyrim first week.

Uncharted 3 lifetime.



Skyrim First Week

Lifetime will come close, but Uncharted 3 will slightly outsell it.



Atto Suggests...:

Book - Malazan Book of the Fallen series 

Game - Metro Last Light

TV - Deadwood

Music - Forest Swords 

Attoyou said:
Skyrim First Week

Lifetime will come close, but Uncharted 3 will slightly outsell it.


Time to change your sig - I'm developing feelings towards it...

 

OT: I have no idea, but I hope UC3 sales are above expectations.