By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - The Uncharted 3 metacritic score! What will it be?

Tagged games:

 

What metacritic score will Uncharted 3 get? (By december)

Below 85 12 2.06%
 
85-90 15 2.57%
 
91 12 2.06%
 
92 24 4.12%
 
93 31 5.32%
 
94 56 9.61%
 
95 84 14.41%
 
96 68 11.66%
 
97 97 16.64%
 
98! 184 31.56%
 
Total:583
yo_john117 on 15 October 2011

I think it will get a 95.

But WTH at so many people thinking it's going to get a 98!??



Around the Network
homer on 15 October 2011

Lower than Gears 3, at least I hope so...



"Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth." -My good friend Mark Aurelius

Aldro on 15 October 2011
x_DMX_x said:
Aldro said:
x_DMX_x said:
Well coming off of almost Naughty Dogs greatest year and all those awards for Uncharted 2.It got 96 on Metacritic right?So judging by that its going to be 96+ on metacritic.I doubt it will be lower because that would just mean the game was worse than its predecessor.


Its not that simple. Any game that has 2-4 points lower than its predecessor is MOST times the better game. To think UC3 will top UC2s insane high score is ..not going to happen. Gears 3 scored 1 pt lower than Gears 2 which scored one point lower than Gears 1. Forza 4 and 3 same applies. If you are a meta whore like myself you will know that by todays standards, if a game is to recieve 2-4 pts lower than its predecessor, it is better. LBP was revolutionary in 08 with 95 meta and most GOTY awards. LBP2 3 years later got 92. Its the first game but a lot more basically. If Un3 gets at the very least 92, itll be considerd a success and solid sequel. If it manages to do what it did in 09, that is left to be seen.

You may be right but I hope you know that Uncahrted 2 is different from all those games.Has Gears won any GOTY awards?What about Forza no.Usualy if a game won GOTY by alot of reviewers most likely they will rate the sequal higher.Look at Uncharted 1 for example it was good but not on Uncharted 2's level.Then Uncahrted 2 got better and so on.So what im saying is Uncharted can only get better.Even if Uncahrted 3 gets a 95 I can honestly say Uncahrted 2 is the best SINGLE PLAYER game ive played this generation yes meaning better single player than any Xbox360 exclusive and PS3 exclusive.

Gears of War 1 won plenty of GOTY awards in 2006 ;D.



Aldro on 15 October 2011
d21lewis said:
I chose 92%. I expect it to have some of the best graphics we'll ever see and some set pieces that will blow us away. I don't know what the story is going to be. So why so low?

Lately, even when games throw some new stuff in and polish their core gameplay (Gears, LBP, Batman) and are really well made, reviewers aren't cutting them any slack. Despite tremendous differences, variety, and presentation, they're saying "Oh, it's just more of the same." As good as Uncharted 3 is likely to be, I suspect that any improvements in online, story, graphics, and control will be ignored by an elite few reviewers. They'll give it 8.5/10. Uncharted has gunplay, climbing, and great graphics. Unless they add Pokemon collecting, a card game, a precise driving in an open world environment, an RPG level-up system, and other things that Uncharted players don't even want or need, Uncharted 3 won't go higher than a 92.

See my signature.

I completely agree with you. I see a lot of 8-9's for this game, whilst Uncharted 2 on Meta only had 1 below 89 ..OUT OF 105! With 39 perfect scores...

 

Ain't going to happen folkes.. aint going to happen *sadface :(



x_DMX_x on 15 October 2011
Aldro said:
x_DMX_x said:
Aldro said:
x_DMX_x said:
Well coming off of almost Naughty Dogs greatest year and all those awards for Uncharted 2.It got 96 on Metacritic right?So judging by that its going to be 96+ on metacritic.I doubt it will be lower because that would just mean the game was worse than its predecessor.


Its not that simple. Any game that has 2-4 points lower than its predecessor is MOST times the better game. To think UC3 will top UC2s insane high score is ..not going to happen. Gears 3 scored 1 pt lower than Gears 2 which scored one point lower than Gears 1. Forza 4 and 3 same applies. If you are a meta whore like myself you will know that by todays standards, if a game is to recieve 2-4 pts lower than its predecessor, it is better. LBP was revolutionary in 08 with 95 meta and most GOTY awards. LBP2 3 years later got 92. Its the first game but a lot more basically. If Un3 gets at the very least 92, itll be considerd a success and solid sequel. If it manages to do what it did in 09, that is left to be seen.

You may be right but I hope you know that Uncahrted 2 is different from all those games.Has Gears won any GOTY awards?What about Forza no.Usualy if a game won GOTY by alot of reviewers most likely they will rate the sequal higher.Look at Uncharted 1 for example it was good but not on Uncharted 2's level.Then Uncahrted 2 got better and so on.So what im saying is Uncharted can only get better.Even if Uncahrted 3 gets a 95 I can honestly say Uncahrted 2 is the best SINGLE PLAYER game ive played this generation yes meaning better single player than any Xbox360 exclusive and PS3 exclusive.

Gears of War 1 won plenty of GOTY awards in 2006 ;D.

Ok you got me.It may have won a couple of GOTY awards but, here is the real question did it reach the amazing success that Uncahrted 2 did?No it did not so really comparing the two games which I just did isnt the answer.What im trying to say is Uncahrted 2 is different from those games because it won ALOT more.



Around the Network
Chevinator123 on 15 October 2011

94



Wagram on 15 October 2011

5 People said below 85.

Obviously they have never played Uncharted.



Kantor on 15 October 2011

I said 95.

And then I saw the trailer.

So, 95-97, because giving one score in that range is silly.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Attoyou on 15 October 2011
homer said:
Lower than Gears 3, at least I hope so...

Go ahead and give up that sig.



Atto Suggests...:

Book - Malazan Book of the Fallen series 

Game - Metro Last Light

TV - Deadwood

Music - Forest Swords 

yo_john117 on 15 October 2011
x_DMX_x said:
Aldro said:
x_DMX_x said:
Aldro said:
x_DMX_x said:
Well coming off of almost Naughty Dogs greatest year and all those awards for Uncharted 2.It got 96 on Metacritic right?So judging by that its going to be 96+ on metacritic.I doubt it will be lower because that would just mean the game was worse than its predecessor.


Its not that simple. Any game that has 2-4 points lower than its predecessor is MOST times the better game. To think UC3 will top UC2s insane high score is ..not going to happen. Gears 3 scored 1 pt lower than Gears 2 which scored one point lower than Gears 1. Forza 4 and 3 same applies. If you are a meta whore like myself you will know that by todays standards, if a game is to recieve 2-4 pts lower than its predecessor, it is better. LBP was revolutionary in 08 with 95 meta and most GOTY awards. LBP2 3 years later got 92. Its the first game but a lot more basically. If Un3 gets at the very least 92, itll be considerd a success and solid sequel. If it manages to do what it did in 09, that is left to be seen.

You may be right but I hope you know that Uncahrted 2 is different from all those games.Has Gears won any GOTY awards?What about Forza no.Usualy if a game won GOTY by alot of reviewers most likely they will rate the sequal higher.Look at Uncharted 1 for example it was good but not on Uncharted 2's level.Then Uncahrted 2 got better and so on.So what im saying is Uncharted can only get better.Even if Uncahrted 3 gets a 95 I can honestly say Uncahrted 2 is the best SINGLE PLAYER game ive played this generation yes meaning better single player than any Xbox360 exclusive and PS3 exclusive.

Gears of War 1 won plenty of GOTY awards in 2006 ;D.

Ok you got me.It may have won a couple of GOTY awards but, here is the real question did it reach the amazing success that Uncahrted 2 did?No it did not so really comparing the two games which I just did isnt the answer.What im trying to say is Uncahrted 2 is different from those games because it won ALOT more.

0_o