I chose 92%. I expect it to have some of the best graphics we'll ever see and some set pieces that will blow us away. I don't know what the story is going to be. So why so low?
Lately, even when games throw some new stuff in and polish their core gameplay (Gears, LBP, Batman) and are really well made, reviewers aren't cutting them any slack. Despite tremendous differences, variety, and presentation, they're saying "Oh, it's just more of the same." As good as Uncharted 3 is likely to be, I suspect that any improvements in online, story, graphics, and control will be ignored by an elite few reviewers. They'll give it 8.5/10. Uncharted has gunplay, climbing, and great graphics. Unless they add Pokemon collecting, a card game, a precise driving in an open world environment, an RPG level-up system, and other things that Uncharted players don't even want or need, Uncharted 3 won't go higher than a 92.
See my signature.
I completely agree with you. I see a lot of 8-9's for this game, whilst Uncharted 2 on Meta only had 1 below 89 ..OUT OF 105! With 39 perfect scores...
Ain't going to happen folkes.. aint going to happen *sadface :(