Skyward Sword does look pretty bad, lets be honest. Forget for a moment the fact it has Zelda in the title and just look at the gameplay. Pretty weak.

ahhh!!! there was spoilers for Uncharted 3!

Exactly. The games has very very weak gameplay. So, Ghirahim take Link's sword and attacks him? pfff, do you need to mix shield and sword attacks to defeat him at the first battle?

Let look at the bettle or the bird, you have to control like a plane as Wii Sports Resorts? The bow? or the Whip? Weak. Do you have to swing your sword on different directions because the foes are covering? Weeeaak

Seriously, no. Just no.

yeah all 4 of 'em

and what idiot goes to this spastic site? i cant remember the last time they talked positive on Nintendo. Everyone knows they hate Nintendo, its no secret at all. lol

Adam Sessler is the only normal bloke in G4. I mean atleast he doesnt sound like a asshole in his opinions, even if he agrees with that Bottom Feeder.

This means that they are going to give Skyward Sword a 3/5 right?

I guess that's better than an ugly 8.8.

Well, I lost all respect for her after her SMG2 rant, I mean, it was her opinion, but it was still immature.

First off it looks terrible. It looks like its from about 2005, 360 launch games look better.

Secondly the entire combat is motion controls so that'll be hit or miss depending on the player and if he likes motion gaming or not. 

Just look at this dude http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m1Z-P-RBzmw Like from around 2:00 on its some boss battle and she has to do is run around and then wave her arms around to swing the sword. Like yeah i guess its cool the way you swing your arms is how link uses his sword, but I don't want to play a game that's as long as Zelda with motion controls the entire time.

There's no way in hell this game will hold a candle to Ocarina of Time. Zelda is one game that should not have gone the way of motion controls. Plus its been in development about 5 years it took almost as long as GT5 to make and you get a game that's graphically not even as good as 360 launch titles?

Just forget its Zelda for a second and look at it objectively. 

THIS

Evolution of Gameplay and Uncharted in the same sentence?

i'm i the only sane person that doesn't see how Uncharted evolved from the first game? , Cover, shoot, puzzle, repeat.

and Skyward Sword is not different from Ocarina Of Time? , give me a fucking break, in my opinion OOT is the most overrated game of all time, the zelda games that came out after it, are much better, i hate how OOT is the "be all . end all" game that "fans" like, admit it, its not because its the best, its because its the first 3D Zelda game you've played, if you take off your nostalgia glassess , you'll see that the next zelda games after it are actually much better games.

that G4 girl is just trying too hard to sound and "Extreme!!!!!!!!!!!!!111 hardcore gaemr gurl!"  , i bet she doesn't even know what a video game is.