Reach outclasses R2 in every category. I also hated the controls and the weapons in R2, the only good thing I liked about R2 was the 64 player online matches. Reach is leagues above R2.

Looks like Reach is winning so far. What should the next game be... Reach vs GT5? Nah that would cause way too many riots. Anyone thinking of anything

Project Gotham Racing 4 vs Motorstorm: Pacific Rift

well if you really want to comapre racers why not GT5 vs Forza 3. That sounds fair enough.

Wow I never thought that people would hat RE2 this much. It amazes me. The MP was fantastic! And the SP was hard as hell! No wonder it got poor sales. Should have compared maybe Killzone 3 with Reach hmmm that sounds like a good idea.

But all this top tier this gen comparisons have been done to death...its boooring.

Why don't we compare Battletoads...SNES version VS Genesis version VS NES version.

RE2 is good but not great... I fell like RE1 is a better game after all... to be fair I'm talking more about the SP because I didn't spend much time with MP (I'm a Uncharted 2 and Killzone 3 MP lover).

Yup I can't get over Uncharted 2 and Killzone 3 MP. Thinking of comparing Killzone 3 with Reach. Don't want to compare Unchared 2 with Halo Reach becuase then it will be way too unfair. It will be more like 100-1 Uncharted 2. Don't want that happening (;

We've had enough of those. And we've had a lot of Killzone 3 vs  Reach. Here are some more possibilities:

Valkryria Chronicles vs Mass Effect

MAG vs Splinter Cell: Conviction

Not really a brained this one. Reach is an amazing game. Best shooter the Gen has seen. Its like comparing a ford to a Ferrari.

Reach.