By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
 

What do you think the future of this thread should be

Comparing Third Party Series 21 36.21%
 
Comparing Third Party Games 16 27.59%
 
Locked 20 34.48%
 
Total:57

Welcome to Head to Head.

 

- I will be putting games from either PS3 or 360 and asking whichever game wins goes to the next round and the other game gets disqualified. For example: (Metal Gear Solid 4 gets 27 votes and Gears of War 2 gets 21 votes MGS4 goes to next round and Gears 2 gets disqaulifed)

- Please just don't vote. Try to explain why you think the game is better. It will make you seem less of a fanboy.

- The two games will always be exlcusives. One from PS3 the other from 360.

-I will change the game in 1-7 days. Depending how good or bad the thread becomes and how fair the game choice is.

Round 2 rules:

 

News feed!

*Reach has won with 59 votes compared to Resistance 2's 36 votes. Halo Reach goes on to next round. RE2 is eliminated.

*Metal Gear Solid 4 beat out Gears of War 2 97-43 votes. MGS4 goes on to next round and Gears of War 2 is eliminated,

*GT5 took 124 of the votes as opposed to Forza 3's 63. GT5 goes to the next round. Forza

*Heavy Rain crushed Alan Wake by 121- 81. Heavy Rain proceeds to the next round.

*God of War 3 destoryed Fable 3 by 68-13. God of War 3 moves on.

*Gears of War beat Resistance Fall of Man by 25-15. Gears of War goes to the next round.

*Mass Effect has beaten Uncharted DF 61-59. Mass Effect goes to the next round.

*Killzone 3 wins 59-23. Killzone 3 goes to the next round.

*Valkryia Chronicles wins against Lost Odyessy. VC goes to the next round.

*Halo 3 defeats Warhawk 40-20. Halo 3 proceeds on to the next round.

*Killzone 2 surpassed L4D 38-24. Killzone 2 proceeds to the next round.

Uncharted 2 beat Halo 3 ODST 77-25. Uncharted 2 moves on.

*Mass Effect 2 gets in round 2 because there were not many 360 games.

*Killzone 3 is out becuase it came in last place in eliminations round.

*There is one extra PS3 game 6-4 so which one deserves to got to round 3?

*Halo Reach will get an extra life as thier are less 360 games.

*Uncharted 2 gets promoted to Round 3!

*God of War 3 goes on to round 3 and Gears of War came in 12th place. God of War 3 won 96-39.

*GT5 wins 61-48. Halo Reach still has one more life left due to less Xbox excluisves. GT5 goes on to round 3.

*MGS4 goes on to round 3 ME2 is disqaulifed. MGS4 won 56-34. MGS4 goes on to round 3.

Halo 3 wins 37-35 against Killzone 2. Killzone 2 is out. Halo 3 goes on to round 3.

VC wins 57-41. Mass Effect is disqualifed. VC goes on to round 3

Halo Reach gets promotes to round 3 and Heavy Rain is eliminated. (59-56)

GT5 gets finishes at 8th and VC goes on to the next round. (29-26)

Metal Gear Solid 4 crushes Halo 3. MGS4 goes on to the next round Halo 3 finishes in 7th place.

God of War 3 surprisingly destoryed Uncharted 2 93-59! God of War 3 moves on to the next round and Uncharted 2 finishes in 6th place.

Halo Reach beats out Killzone 3 61-47 and moves on to the semi finals. Killzone 3 finishes in 5th place

MGS4 is in the finals. VC ended in 4th place!

God of War 3 terminates Halo Reach 181-55! Halo Reach is third. God of War 3 is in the finals!

God of War 3 destoryed MGS4 258-169 and has won the thread! Metal Gear Solid 4 came in a close second.

 

Round 2: Halo Reach vs Metal Gear Solid 4 vs GT5 vs Heavy Rain vs God of War 3 vs Gears of War vs Mass Effect vs Killzone 3 vs VC vs Halo 3 vs Killzone 2 vs Uncharted 2.

 

Resistance 2 vs Halo Reach  - Halo Reach

Metal Gear Solid 4 vs Gears of War 2 - Metal Gear Solid 4

Gran Turismo 5 vs Forza 3 - Gran Turismo 5

Heavy Rain vs Alan Wake  - Heavy Rain

God of War 3 vs Fable 3  - God of War 3

Resistance Fall of Man vs Gears of War - Gears of War

Uncharted DF vs Mass Effect - Mass Effect

Killzone 3 vs Left 4 dead 2  - Killzone 3

Valekra Chronicles vs Lost Odyessy - Valkeria Chronicles

Warhawk vs Halo 3 - Halo 3

Killzone 2 vs Left 4 Dead - Killzone 2

Uncharted 2 vs  Halo 3 ODST -Uncharted 2

 

Round 2:

God of War 3 vs Gears of War - God of War 3 (96-39)

GT5 vs Halo Reach - GT5 (61-48)

Metal Gear Solid 4 vs Mass Effect 2 - MGS4 (56-34)

Killzone 2 vs Halo 3 - Halo 3 (37-35)

Mass Effect vs Valkyria Chronicles - Valkyria Chronicles (57-41)

Heavy Rain vs Halo Reach - Halo Reach (59-56)

 

Round 3:

       Gran Turismo 5 vs Valkyria Chronicles - VC (31-27)

Halo 3 vs Metal Gear Solid 4 - Metal Gear Solid 4 - (52-22)

God of War 3 vs Uncharted 2 - God of War 3 (93-59)

Killzone 3 vs Halo Reach - Halo Reach (61-47)

 

Round 4 (Semi Finals)

Metal Gear Solid 4 vs Valkyria Chronciles -  MGS4 (48-37)

God of War 3 vs Halo Reach - God of War 3 (181 -55)

 

Finals!!!

God of War 3 vs Metal Gear Sold 4 -

 

 

 

 

 

 

Winners:

12. Mass Effect 2

11. Killzone 2

10. Mass Effect

9. Heavy Rain

8. Halo Reach

7. Halo 3

6.Uncharted 2

5. Killzone 3

4. Valkyria Chronciles

3. Gran Turismo 5

2. Metal Gear Solid 4

1. God of War 3



Around the Network

Resistance 2 wasn't that good to begin with so ..... Halo Reach



I don't like either, so I voted Resistance 2, don't know why xD.



SP: I must go with Halo: Reach just because I absolutely loved the story, it made the spartans look human and that they need to rely on each other, rather than just the gun-slinging, lone-wolf that was masterchief. and I found R2's story kinda weak.

MP: I would give this to Resistance 2, i like R2's huge maps and player count.(though Halo: Reach MP was great as well)

but I'm going to give this to Halo Reach.




More appropriate would be to wait till Resistance 3 comes out then compare. R2 is WAY older than Reach.



PSN: Saugeen-Uwo     Feel free to add me (put Vg Chartz as MSG)!

Nintendo Network ID: Saugeen-Uwo

Around the Network

I voted for resistance purely on the 8 player online coop , half of my friends list came out of that mode , so any game that can do that is ok. having voted that way i can see why the majority will vote for reach its a great FPS.



Research shows Video games  help make you smarter, so why am I an idiot

Resistance 2 was awful and the single worst big PS3 exclusive

Halo Reach is one of the greatest shooters ever created, its superior to Resistance 2 in every single aspect.



So I vote Halo Reach.



Pfft...everyone knows Resistance and Gears are supposed to go head to head.



Reach is not the best Halo (Halo 3 is) but it is better than Resistance 2 (the first one is better)... the multilayer in Reach is so crazy.



disolitude said:
Pfft...everyone knows Resistance and Gears are supposed to go head to head.


So which one do you vote for