Quantcast
Will MHP3 HD remake for PS3 outsell MH3 for Wii (in Japan)?

Forums - Sales Discussion - Will MHP3 HD remake for PS3 outsell MH3 for Wii (in Japan)?

Will MHP3 HD remake for PS3 outsell MH3 for Wii (in Japan)?

yes 152 51.70%
 
no 142 48.30%
 
Total:294
Carl2291 said:
ElGranCabeza said:

0% chance. It'll sell ~200k tops.

"3DS to kick Sony out of the handheld market. Sell 300 million units LTD at the very least."

So in reality, MH PS3 will sell like 600k.


Wanna bet?



Around the Network
ElGranCabeza said:

Wanna bet?

Sure, go for it. When MH PS3 sells more than 200k then I get your avatar and sig for a Month, yes?



Carl2291 said:
ElGranCabeza said:

Wanna bet?

Sure, go for it. When MH PS3 sells more than 200k then I get your avatar and sig for a Month, yes?


Terms of bet:

If MH PS3 port sells 600k or more, you get control of my avatar and sig for a month

Else if MH PS3 port sells 200k or less, I get control of your avatar and sig for a month

Else nothing happens

 

Deal or no deal?



Immortal said:

Am I the only one who thinks this question is delusional? All of one game has ever topped 1m in Japan on the PS3 and people expect a port to do that well? Really? I don't believe the PS3 can handle games that actually sell a decent amount. I mean, even the mighty Final Fantasy - the franchise which topped 1m for the PS3 - had pretty messed up numbers for its franchise on the console.

If MH3 game had sold under 500k on Wii, then it'd be possible, even likely, but I don't think there's any hope whatsoever of MHP3 pulling this off.

'Course, MH has been defying expectations so I suppose this is possible...

Monster Hunter is a bigger franchise than FF in Japan and there has never been a MH game on the PS3 before. 



ElGranCabeza said:

Terms of bet:

If MH PS3 port sells 600k or more, you get control of my avatar and sig for a month

Else if MH PS3 port sells 200k or less, I get control of your avatar and sig for a month

Else nothing happens

 

Deal or no deal?

That's not fair to Carl, because he is a man of honor. The treshold for him to win the bet will be 800k, because that's what he originally said.

Alternatively, there's no "nothing happens" option. With 500k being exactly in the middle of your two predictions, the winner will be decided by whether it's over or under this number.



Legend11 correctly predicted that GTA IV (360+PS3) would outsell SSBB. I was wrong.

A Biased Review Reloaded / Open Your Eyes / Switch Gamers Club

Around the Network
RolStoppable said:
ElGranCabeza said:

Terms of bet:

If MH PS3 port sells 600k or more, you get control of my avatar and sig for a month

Else if MH PS3 port sells 200k or less, I get control of your avatar and sig for a month

Else nothing happens

 

Deal or no deal?

That's not fair to Carl, because he is a man of honor. The treshold for him to win the bet will be 800k, because that's what he originally said.

Alternatively, there's no "nothing happens" option. With 500k being exactly in the middle of your two predictions, the winner will be decided by whether it's over or under this number.


I can accept this alternative bet terms.



ElGranCabeza said:

Terms of bet:

If MH PS3 port sells 600k or more, you get control of my avatar and sig for a month

Else if MH PS3 port sells 200k or less, I get control of your avatar and sig for a month

Else nothing happens 

Deal or no deal?

Sure, If it doesn't reach 600k though I'm still gonna mock you when it flies past 200k...



Yea 2 million at least.



Carl2291 said:
ElGranCabeza said:

Terms of bet:

If MH PS3 port sells 600k or more, you get control of my avatar and sig for a month

Else if MH PS3 port sells 200k or less, I get control of your avatar and sig for a month

Else nothing happens 

Deal or no deal?

Sure, If it doesn't reach 600k though I'm still gonna mock you when it flies past 200k...

There is an alternative bet term that the people think it's fairer. 



ElGranCabeza said:

There is an alternative bet term that the people think it's fairer. 

I think you should see this -

http://gamrreview.vgchartz.com/sales/42875/monster-hunter-frontier-online/

Yes. A 3 Year old port of a PC game even managed to break 130k on the Xbox 360 in Japan. A ~1 Year port of the best selling 3rd party game ever in Japan will breeze past 200k.