By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Anonymous Explains why they hacked Ps3. April 21/22 2011

lol, epic. Hey guys, get a clue and watch the last vid in the OP. Anon specifically states that their taking down PSN was a mistake. These guys are geniouse IMO.



"with great power, comes great responsibility."

Around the Network

Interesting philosophical divide. I, myself have argued what they argue in earlier threads when the GeoHot case first broke. I was playing the devil's advocate to get a better understanding of the flaws of their argument.

Basically, Anonymous believes that if you own your console you have every right to tinker with it and modify it in any way, shape, or form you want to.

Here is where their fundamental belief runs into conflict:

1. If a PS3 is connected to PSN it will receive updates (for free btw) from Sony.

2. PSN since the release of the PS3 has been free. Sony would argue they are giving every single PS3 user a massive charitable donation because the alternative (Xbox Live) is fee-to-play.

3. Video game consoles do not equal personal computers. Many, including myself, will concede video game consoles are becoming more like personal computers on the cheap with every next generation.

I disagree with Anonymous philosophically. My disagreement rests entirely with the network and online capabilities, even if you pay for it. Going further, I agree that there are things I cannot and should never do on my PC.

For example, I own a computer and can tinker around and modify it to a large degree. That being said, living in a society of laws, there are areas which are patently illegal such as child pornography, online piracy, and hacking.

No excuse in the world justifies illegal behavior. I don't care if you are starving and need to steal a loaf of bread to feed your child. Your actions will be passed onto another and they will learn from you that illegal behavior is acceptable.

Once we make one exception then you have to condone it for everyone. If you allow the starving man to steal a loaf of bread, then you as a society or group of individuals sanction those who are the most powerful and materially successful in your society or group to screw over the weakest to further their ends.

Anonymous from their videos seems to believe their illegal hacking is for the good of the Sony consumer. Why should their hacking be condoned, while when someone hacks and steals thousands of credit cards is chased to the ends of the Earth?

Anonymous hacking PSN is equally as bad as any other form of hacking. Their behavior should not be condoned no matter the reason because if we condone their behavior than who are we to doubt the hacker who stole thousands of credit card numbers did not steal them so that he can donate their balances to feeding the poor people in Africa?



"FUCKING CUNT CUNT FUCKING CUNT FUCKING FUCK!!!!!!"

That is how I feel about not being able to play MK online for 4 fucking cunt days, god dammit

That is all.



fps_d0minat0r said:
Mr Khan said:
fps_d0minat0r said:
Mr Khan said:
fps_d0minat0r said:
Mr Khan said:

Sony messed with consumers' rights, and now faces the consequences. I can't condone this one because it is illegal, but it's a natural consequence to Sony's bullying


banning pirates and cheaters is bullying?

if it is then whats wrong with it?

if i made a game and i realised someone was copying it, i would beat the shit out of them....atleast sony are not going to that extent.

We go back to the fact that GeoHotz was excercising his protected consumers' rights which caused piracy through no legal fault of his own, and Sony decided to target him because they couldn't deal with the broader piracy, or just because they figured they could lawyer him out of existence (which they more or less did as far as it pertains to the PS3). They lashed out at the innocent because they could not cope with their own problems. In the legal world, bullying. Anonymous is calling them out on it. They're combatting illegalities with illegalities, but Sony stepped outside the lines first


without jailbreak there would be no piracy. geo hot released jailbreak fully knowing it would lead to piracy.

its like drink driving, no-one has the intention of running someone over but if you drink and drive, its bound to happen and you pay the consequences if it does.

If we were to assign Hotz blame in this allegorical scenario, he would better fit the bartender. He just sells the stuff, where it goes is not his problem, and it would be equally erroneous to blame him.


no the bartenders would be the shops selling jailbreak.

there would be nothing wrong with geo hot drinking (hacking) but the problem occurs when he gets in his car (risking everyone else, in our case PSN users) and even though his intent isnt to run someone over (piracy, cheating), its still very likely to happen.

its a fact geohot knew that releasing jailbreak would lead to substantial levels of piracy and cheating and if you do not acknowledge that fact then you bare no credibility and therefore i dont want to debate it with you.

anyways if he was right, why did he back down despite having financial funds and support from the hacking community including anonymous? actually dont answer that because there is no real answer for that.... probably only a few excuses.

 

Let us run with your analogy of drinking. Do you remember prohibition? Do you remember what a fucking idiotic idea it was? End of story.

Also as far as companies go Sony is a fucking piece of shit company that doesn't deserve to exist. First this fucking bullshit where they think the product is their own AFTER we buy it and we can't share how to do things with it. Then if you remember they put in rootkits on their CDs. That was also to prevent piracy. The sooner the fucktards of SONY go out of business the happier I will be.



Tag(thx fkusumot) - "Yet again I completely fail to see your point..."

HD vs Wii, PC vs HD: http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/thread.php?id=93374

Why Regenerating Health is a crap game mechanic: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3986420

gamrReview's broken review scores: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4170835

 

Funny Geohut WON the same lawsuit that Apples slapped him with that Sony's doing now. He's the one who raps about Sony, then talks big about Sony in interviews, and then flees the country? WTF? He's making himself look guilty it's his EGO why this whole thing is the way it is. He is such a TOOL(keyword remember that) all this for nothing really.

 

IDK why encourage people to hack the PSN like that's gonna make Sony back down. Only made about 90% of the PS3 owners pissed. Who knows who caused this PSN outage If it was him and his minions well not just everyone hates you but there can be criminal charges coming your way.

 

At the end of the day your just ruining the consumers purchuse just cause you have a beef with them. All this for well nothing he didn't do this on Apple's why do it now?

 

There Kamiyama's common sense



"We don't always hack sites but when we do, we prefer Sony"-Anonymous

http://www.cristgaming.com/pirate.swf

Around the Network
richardhutnik said:
Baalzamon said:

Are you fucking kidding me?  They aren't trying to attack users, it wasn't their goal to do this?  What the fuck did they think would happen if they attacked psn and brought it down?  Did they think anything except us users being affected would happen?  Fuck you anonymous, don't tell me you're on my side, because you are a bunch of douchebags that aren't on anybody's side.

What part of denying they had something to do with it has slipped your notice?  Just because the original poster tried to spin what happened that way doesn't mean it is how it happened.

And no, Anonymous isn't on anyone's side.  Anonymous is a loosely connected of community that operates behind masks, and will express sometimes contradicting opinions.  There is some shared values between the individuals, born out of the culture of the Internet.  Anonymous just is.  Whether or not you feel a culture of hiding behind masks and acting should be stamped out and everyone be identified all the time, and everything that is done in private shoiuld be revealed to the world, would be up to you.

Sorry, I haven’t put a spin on anything; the original post was almost entirely from the videos YouTube description, listen to the part of the video at 1:25 minutes in which Anonymous explains that it was a mistake to attack PSN and the video is really the important part of the post not the text. I only ever brought this to everyone’s attention here because this is a forum for gamers that also share my concern about the disruption this attack has caused us and to maybe shed some light on the situation.       





Xenostar said:
ssj12 said:
Wagram said:
SmokedHostage said:

I hope they keep the PSN down for quite some time.

Is it so wrong to be wanting to see Sony burn?


So you want the other 49.5M people with PS3s to suffer too? Anonymous is a bunch of jackasses.

I'm not mad at Sony and i'll be sure to set my friends straight if they think this is Sonys fault.

Its entirely Sony's fault.

If ssj12 is a writer for this website as it suggests under his avatar, i hope he gets fired.


Is it so wrong to be wanting to see ssj12 burn?


Nope.



ssj12 said:
deskpro2k3 said:
ssj12 said:
Kamiyama said:

So they're the reason for the new systems?  Amazing!!!!!! So anonymous is the reason we're getting PS4,Xbox 720 and the Wii2? Wow Anonymous is perfect! Ok so if i mess around with my car i can make a jet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thanks ssj12! 




truthfully, I see no issue with that, if you can make yourself a flying jet car all the power to you. If that is what you dream of doing, no one should be able to stop you, only you can stop you. Follow your goal till the end.


I'm going to go make copies of that car key and teach people how to do it, and I'll take the credit for it.

would be kind of worthless as each vehicle would have a separate key specially sliced to fit only one lock/ignition combo. you would only be able to get into one car.

Ok how do you parallel park a jet?



"We don't always hack sites but when we do, we prefer Sony"-Anonymous

http://www.cristgaming.com/pirate.swf

Kamiyama said:
ssj12 said:
deskpro2k3 said:
ssj12 said:
Kamiyama said:

So they're the reason for the new systems?  Amazing!!!!!! So anonymous is the reason we're getting PS4,Xbox 720 and the Wii2? Wow Anonymous is perfect! Ok so if i mess around with my car i can make a jet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thanks ssj12! 




truthfully, I see no issue with that, if you can make yourself a flying jet car all the power to you. If that is what you dream of doing, no one should be able to stop you, only you can stop you. Follow your goal till the end.


I'm going to go make copies of that car key and teach people how to do it, and I'll take the credit for it.

would be kind of worthless as each vehicle would have a separate key specially sliced to fit only one lock/ignition combo. you would only be able to get into one car.

Ok how do you parallel park a jet?


we are talking a jet car arent we? I'd assume it would be like James Bond's car submarine. And I think he had a flying  car too, forget. Simply park it after it retracts its wings.



PC gaming is better than console gaming. Always.     We are Anonymous, We are Legion    Kick-ass interview   Great Flash Series Here    Anime Ratings     Make and Play Please
Amazing discussion about being wrong
Official VGChartz Folding@Home Team #109453
 
Mr Khan said:

Sony messed with consumers' rights, and now faces the consequences. I can't condone this one because it is illegal, but it's a natural consequence to Sony's bullying


Anon messes with consumer's rights now, hopefully they will face the consequences.