Ninja gaiden 2. God of war 3 is a slow mans hack and slash. Kratos wouldn´t even see Ryu.

gw3, weapons are amazing.

Devil May Cry 4, followed by Bayonetta.

God Of War 3 (9.3/10) and Ninja Gaiden 2 a second close (9.2/10).

Bayonneta is meh... 7/10 for me.

Dantes Inferno is boring (5.0/10)

I didn't play Castlevania and  Ninja Blade.

god of war 3 for sure although i like the look of metal gear rising

what about darksiders?

Easily GoW 3 for me. But, Ninja Gaiden 2 come a second close though.

These "polls" are getting ridiculous. There is no way this is that one sided.

Well you have to take into account GOW is the best selling Hack and Slash game on that list by a country mile.

Sales wise:

Ninja Gaiden 2 = 1 million.

Castlevania (both platforms) = 820k .

Bayonetta (both platforms) = 1.7 million.

Dante's Inferno (both platforms) = 1.54 million

Ninja Blade = 250k

God Of War III = 3.71 million.

It's reached a much bigger audience of players, so they may well vote for it over the other games they haven't played.

God of War III with ease