By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - EGM reviews LBP2, Lost in Shadow, GT5 *shocks included!*

Sensei on 07 January 2011

Troll magazine or what? This is pathetic. GT5 might not be a 10 but it certainly isn't a 6.5...



Around the Network
cr00mz on 07 January 2011

how can this thread be only at 5 pages? i expected more raging

i need entertainment!!



d21lewis on 07 January 2011

Before the revamp, EGM was my favorite gaming publication of all time.  I have decades of issues in my closet.  This new EGM feels nothing likr the old.  I bought the Gears 3 issue and while it was good, I felt like I would never buy another issue.  I may pick this one up just to read the contraversy but I don't know.

And a thread with that review in the title would get 200 replies.



ethomaz on 07 January 2011
Darth Tigris said:

2) Those tripping over the LBP2 score .... again, REALLY???!!!  It's a sad world we live in when 8.5 is considered a bad score.  Some 8.5's that I've played are among my favorite games ever.  What is the problem with that score????!!!

Nothing but LBP receive a 9 or 10... so why LBP2 receive a 8.5??? The game is way (far way) better than the first one (I know I'm early beta).



NiKKoM on 07 January 2011

Aw... GT5 didn't get a 11... I'm angry!



 

Face the future.. Gamecenter ID: nikkom_nl (oh no he didn't!!) 

Around the Network
cr00mz on 07 January 2011
ethomaz said:
Darth Tigris said:

2) Those tripping over the LBP2 score .... again, REALLY???!!!  It's a sad world we live in when 8.5 is considered a bad score.  Some 8.5's that I've played are among my favorite games ever.  What is the problem with that score????!!!

Nothing but LBP receive a 9 or 10... so why LBP2 receive a 8.5??? The game is way (far way) better than the first one (I know I'm early beta).

the guy reviewing LPB2 obviously thinks the game is worse than the first, therefore he gave it a worse score. Maybe you should start your own magazine and give LBP2 a 10 then.



PhantomLink on 07 January 2011
cr00mz said:

how can this thread be only at 5 pages? i expected more raging

i need entertainment!!

That's because everyone is playing GT5 right now.



Why don't you make like a tree and get out of here?

ethomaz on 07 January 2011
cr00mz said:
ethomaz said:
Darth Tigris said:

2) Those tripping over the LBP2 score .... again, REALLY???!!!  It's a sad world we live in when 8.5 is considered a bad score.  Some 8.5's that I've played are among my favorite games ever.  What is the problem with that score????!!!

Nothing but LBP receive a 9 or 10... so why LBP2 receive a 8.5??? The game is way (far way) better than the first one (I know I'm early beta).

the guy reviewing LPB2 obviously thinks the game is worse than the first, therefore he gave it a worse score. Maybe you should start your own magazine and give LBP2 a 10 then.

The guy said LBP2 is better than LBP but the single player is too short.

Sorry... but bias is bias.



Tommie on 07 January 2011

I think its crazy for people to go all raging about the 8.5 LBP2 score already. I mean the game isn't even out yet, and none of you have even played the full game, so you can't really judge if the game will surpass the quality of the first game. Maybe, just maybe, it won't live up to your expectations as well, just like the reviewer. Just saying. 



You aint found shit!

ethomaz on 07 January 2011
Tommie said:

I think its crazy for people to go all raging about the 8.5 LBP2 score already. I mean the game isn't even out yet, and none of you have even played the full game, so you can't really judge if the game will surpass the quality of the first game. Maybe, just maybe, it won't live up to your expectations as well, just like the reviewer. Just saying.

And all other reviews? 10 and 9? Metacritic 93... and the Beta is way better than first one.