Resistance 3 doesn't belong on that list based on the trailer for it.

The trailer looked awesome, significant improvement from R2.

It looks like a game from the start of this generation.  Not only that but the textures, effects, and artwork all look really bad.

Are you serious? Even the Neogaf pixel counters mistook the footage as a stylized cut-scene until Insomniac came on and mentioned that's actual gameplay. With another year of development and judging by the footage that's been shown, it definitely deserves to be nominated.

Oh man, show me an FPS on the market right now besides Killzone 2 that look that good.

Poor textures on the buildings, generic enemies, the list goes on.  Some pixel counters thought it was a stylized cut-scene, maybe they thought it was  Wii game?  If this game gets on the list then over half the HD games coming out in 2011 should be on the list.

Uncharted 3 will kill the competition once AGAIN.

KZ3 and Rage should come as close runner ups and Infamous 2 should be on the list!

WOW........just amazing!

I misread the OP, discard my comment. 

Crysis, Rage...maybe adding links to videos so people can see some of these games in motion. I'm interested in seeing ME3 and Skyrim gameplay; I expect those two to be up there as well.