By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft Discussion - Uncharted 2 > Halo Reach. Is Reach doomed ?

twesterm on 03 December 2010
Yuyyder said:
kowenicki said:

Good Grief.  I'm not sure if you are taking the piss or a bit hard of thought? 

6.5m and almost 200k this week and you think it will struggle to sell 8m? 

hey... here is one for you.... in a similar vein

Forza 3 > Uncharted 2.

Uncharted epic fail... doomed!!!

Pleasee... try harder next time, this is just very very weak.

 

Uncharted 2 lifetime > Forza 3 lifetime

Is forza foomed ?


lol, nvm, this comment wins the thread.



 

Around the Network
Funtime on 03 December 2010
Yuyyder said:

Wow, Uncharted 2 sold more than Halo Reach this week. An amazing feat. Is reach doomed ? I think for certain it is going to sell at most 8million lifetime. A decline to the halo series. It is a good series but definitely not as big as COD, GTA, Pokemon and GT.

None of the series you mentioned is as successful as Mario Kart so they are all doomed too! OH NOES!



Yuyyder on 03 December 2010
Mendicate Bias said:
Yuyyder said:
Mendicate Bias said:

You do realize that one of the most immature things to do is create a troll thread because your upset with a few select individuals.

Not that I'm surprised at the hypocrisy since you've already gone back over your entire argument and then brought up irrelevant points to try and derail your own thread when you saw that you had been called out by the actual intelligent and mature posters of this forum.

Not because I was upset, but rather to see the reaction. Now what is my entire argument when there is none that I begin with ? And what irrelevant points are aimed at derailing my own thread ? I cant really see you know. I can only read from these. I suppose you are intelligent enough, so point me to my original argument will you ? Seeing I dont rem making one in the first place.

Are you serious? Your argument is in the title of your post and its in your OP where you asked if Reach is doomed and that you think it will only sell 8 million despite any sane person being able to see that it will easily go past that.

Not to mention you have brought up lifetime sales of the GT series and the original xbox despite it having nothing to do with your original argument. This is completely ignoring the fact that your berated someone for stating the exact same thing you did in your opening post.

Everyone can see what your trying to do and you've backed yourself up into a corner so there's no point in making you look any worst, I'm done talking to you.

How is the title an argument when its a question ? I was asking for opinions. Perhaps you need to buy a new sarcasm reactor ? I have answered each of your question while you have just sweetly skipped mine. Who was it I berated ? An actual link and nick will do. Telling me you are done talking to me just adds on to the cause that you want to have the last word. All right have it. These are my thinking out loud thoughts on your last words.

And stop judging. You played too much Ace Attorney or FF12 ?



Yuyyder on 03 December 2010
Funtime said:
Yuyyder said:

Wow, Uncharted 2 sold more than Halo Reach this week. An amazing feat. Is reach doomed ? I think for certain it is going to sell at most 8million lifetime. A decline to the halo series. It is a good series but definitely not as big as COD, GTA, Pokemon and GT.

None of the series you mentioned is as successful as Mario Kart so they are all doomed too! OH NOES!

I do agree. I suspect the next Mario Kart will certainly sell more than Halo and GT Next ^^



richardhutnik on 03 December 2010
Yuyyder said:

Wow, Uncharted 2 sold more than Halo Reach this week. An amazing feat. Is reach doomed ? I think for certain it is going to sell at most 8million lifetime. A decline to the halo series. It is a good series but definitely not as big as COD, GTA, Pokemon and GT.

If GT5 fails to sell as much as Halo Reach lifetime, does that mean that the Gran Turismo series is doomed, or GT5 specifically is doomed?  Reach has sold nearly 6.5 million copies at this point. Let's say it ends up over 7 million lifetime.  Do you see GT5 exceeding that lifetime?  If so, my how much?