Don't we already have two or three of these?

The legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass / DS :

Super Mario Galaxy / Wii : +4

Metroid Prime 3 Corruption / Wii :

Motorstorm / PS3 :

Halo 3 / X360 :

Bioshock / X360 : +1

Assasins Creed / X360, PS3 :

Mass Effect / X360 :

Haze / PS3 :

Ratchet and Clank Future / PS3 :

Uncharted / PS3 :

Guitar Hero III / X360, PS3, Wii, PS2 :

Rock Band / X360, PS3 :

Resident evil 4 / Wii :

Metal Gear Solid Portable Ops / PSP :

Resident Evil Umbrella Chronicles / Wii :

Zack and Wiki Quest for Barbaros' treasure / Wii :

Ninja Gaiden Sigma / PS3 :

The legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass / DS :

Super Mario Galaxy / Wii : +6

Metroid Prime 3 Corruption / Wii :

Motorstorm / PS3 :

Halo 3 / X360 :

Bioshock / X360 : +1

Assasins Creed / X360, PS3 :

Mass Effect / X360 : +1

Haze / PS3 :

Ratchet and Clank Future / PS3 :

Uncharted / PS3 :

Guitar Hero III / X360, PS3, Wii, PS2 :

Rock Band / X360, PS3 :

Resident evil 4 / Wii :

Metal Gear Solid Portable Ops / PSP :

Resident Evil Umbrella Chronicles / Wii :

Zack and Wiki Quest for Barbaros' treasure / Wii :

Ninja Gaiden Sigma / PS3 :

LAIR: / PS3: +1

just adding people who didnt copy the list 

this list is invalid for lack of Orange Box / PC

SMG will win, just like the ratings in the site it will be taken over.

The legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass / DS :

Super Mario Galaxy / Wii : +6

Metroid Prime 3 Corruption / Wii :

Motorstorm / PS3 :

Halo 3 / X360 :

Bioshock / X360 : +1

Assasins Creed / X360, PS3 :

Mass Effect / X360 : +1

Haze / PS3 :

Ratchet and Clank Future / PS3 :

Uncharted / PS3 :

Guitar Hero III / X360, PS3, Wii, PS2 :

Rock Band / X360, PS3 :

Resident evil 4 / Wii :

Metal Gear Solid Portable Ops / PSP :

Resident Evil Umbrella Chronicles / Wii :

Zack and Wiki Quest for Barbaros' treasure / Wii :

Ninja Gaiden Sigma / PS3 :

LAIR: / PS3: +1

Orange Box / PC: +1 

just adding people who didnt copy the list

If Galaxy is winning so easily here, than why did that other website give the thumbs up to BioShock? Sure, BioShock is good, but Galaxy was at #1 on Game Rankings for a while. That alone should, by default, give it the Game of the Year title!

The legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass / DS :

Super Mario Galaxy / Wii : +7

Metroid Prime 3 Corruption / Wii :

Motorstorm / PS3 :

Halo 3 / X360 :

Bioshock / X360 : +1

Assasins Creed / X360, PS3 :

Mass Effect / X360 : +1

Haze / PS3 :

Ratchet and Clank Future / PS3 :

Uncharted / PS3 :

Guitar Hero III / X360, PS3, Wii, PS2 :

Rock Band / X360, PS3 :

Resident evil 4 / Wii :

Metal Gear Solid Portable Ops / PSP :

Resident Evil Umbrella Chronicles / Wii :

Zack and Wiki Quest for Barbaros' treasure / Wii :

Ninja Gaiden Sigma / PS3 :

LAIR: / PS3: +1 (Alright, who did this?)

The legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass / DS :

Super Mario Galaxy / Wii : +6

Metroid Prime 3 Corruption / Wii :+1

Motorstorm / PS3 :

Halo 3 / X360 :

Bioshock / X360 : +1

Assasins Creed / X360, PS3 :

Mass Effect / X360 : +1

Haze / PS3 :

Ratchet and Clank Future / PS3 :

Uncharted / PS3 :

Guitar Hero III / X360, PS3, Wii, PS2 :

Rock Band / X360, PS3 :

Resident evil 4 / Wii :

Metal Gear Solid Portable Ops / PSP :

Resident Evil Umbrella Chronicles / Wii :

Zack and Wiki Quest for Barbaros' treasure / Wii :

Ninja Gaiden Sigma / PS3 :

LAIR: / PS3: +1

Orange Box / PC: +1

 that site is 360 baised