By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - The great obesity debate.

Slimebeast said:
HappySqurriel said:

I thought I would revive this thread with a question to see people’s opinions on a hypothesis I’ve been developing over the past little while ...

A little over a decade ago, when I was 19 years old, I lost (roughly) 90 pounds and I have mostly kept it off since then. At the time I didn’t follow any structured diet program, and my focus was on eating what I thought was a more appropriate portion size and paying attention to the signals my body was telling me about how I should eat. Over the years I have periodically put back on some of the weight and tried a variety of different methods to take it off with varying results.Recently (as in over the past few years) I have had a growing interest in nutrition in general and I decided to return to the root of my weight loss and focus on listening to my body and eating appropriately; and I have achieved a level of success that has always eluded me.

My hypothesis is that conventional diets do not work; and the reason why the dieting is still so heavily promoted is because the weight-loss industry is big business (over $40 Billion per year) and there isn’t much money in telling people to pay more attention to what their body is telling them.

You're right of course.

Are you over-weight now squirl?


I have always been on the slim side, but i also try to eat almost everything, there are some salads i dont like that much, but i still eat them cause i know they are good for me. I agree with you and i think the main problem is not selecting what you actually eat.

Once/Twice a month i give myself a small prize and i eat not-so-good food, a huge icecream, a huge burger and so on, but i know i just cant eat that everyday cause it would like almost like poison myself in the long term. When i got anxious, i try to eat healthy food, like probiotics-added milk/yogurth, vitamin-added dietary fiber-added cookies, etc, etc.



You may find a mirror trying to find the other side of the world

Around the Network
Slimebeast said:
HappySqurriel said:

I thought I would revive this thread with a question to see people’s opinions on a hypothesis I’ve been developing over the past little while ...

A little over a decade ago, when I was 19 years old, I lost (roughly) 90 pounds and I have mostly kept it off since then. At the time I didn’t follow any structured diet program, and my focus was on eating what I thought was a more appropriate portion size and paying attention to the signals my body was telling me about how I should eat. Over the years I have periodically put back on some of the weight and tried a variety of different methods to take it off with varying results.Recently (as in over the past few years) I have had a growing interest in nutrition in general and I decided to return to the root of my weight loss and focus on listening to my body and eating appropriately; and I have achieved a level of success that has always eluded me.

My hypothesis is that conventional diets do not work; and the reason why the dieting is still so heavily promoted is because the weight-loss industry is big business (over $40 Billion per year) and there isn’t much money in telling people to pay more attention to what their body is telling them.

You're right of course.

Are you over-weight now squirl?

Based on BMI I (just) qualify as "over-weight" but with how fit I am I don't think anyone would say that I was over-weight



It's not how much you eat it's what you eat. I do nothing but snack on junk food most of the time and I'm probably 30 pounds over-weight. I can't remember the last time I ate 3 meals in one day. I work overnights,so that probably has something to do with it. lol