Best Graphics - Assasin's Creed (the game just NAILED the look)
Best Sound Effects - Mass Effect
Best Replay Value - Rock Band (My wife and I play that damn game nearly every night)
Best Music/Soundtrack - Rock Band
Best Story - BioShock (Would you kindly vote for this game?)
Best Multiplayer - Rock Band
Most Innovative Feature in a Game: Portal Gun
Most Innovative Game: Portal
In specific catagories:
Best First/Third Person Shooter: Halo 3
Best Racing Game: [No Vote]
Best RPG: Mass Effect
Best Action/Adventure Game: Assasin's Creed
Best XBLA Game: Switchball
Best Sports Game (new!): [No Vote]
Game of the Year (all genres): Mass Effect (Tough to call against Bioshock, ME wins because of game scale)
Suprise of the Year (new!): Portal
Turd/Letdown of the Year: Two Worlds
Fun Categories:
Year’s funniest vid game moment: Portal "I'm still alive" end credits song
Most quoted line from a vid game line seen on the Internet: Portal..."The Cake is a lie."
Best use of androgynous sex in a vid game: Mass Effect
Best use of hay in a video game: Assasin’s Creed
Best use of groveling in a vid game: Overlord
Best plot twist of the year: Bioshock