http://us.i1.yimg.com/videogames.yahoo.com/feature/critical-hits/1173417

10.  Assassin's Creed

9.  Gears of War  (PC)

8.  

Disgaea: Afternoon of Darkness (PSP) - 87.7%

7.  Uncharted

6.  Crysis

5.  Virtual Fighter

4.  Mass Effect

3.  Rock Band

2.  Call of Duty 4

1.  Super Mario Galaxy

No surprise in #1,  but Uncharted ranked higher than Assassin's Creed is news  to me.

I heard Crysis is awesome!

I've never heard any of you talking about Disgaea - how good is this game?

Why would it be news to you that uncharted is a better game than assassins?

The average is 88 for uncharted with 84 for assassins creed.

I didn't read the scores before. I'm reacting to the sales of the two games.

yep no suprise in no1 and i also think uncharted is better then assassins creed but thats just my opinion

yep sales tell a whole different story

Disgea has an average of 88% on Gamespot

Thats actually a very good list. I have a few in the lower I wouldn't have chosen but thats to be expected. The top 3 or 4 spots are pretty solid choices.

I'd prefer Uncharted over Assassin's Creed any day.

Uncharted is better than AC. The sales for Uncharted should get better when it releases in EU and Japan.

Woo hoo! I'm glad SMG is #1 but disappointed there are no other Wii games up there.