1: Twisted Metal-nostalgia factor really. Plus the intro was great, and the gameplay looks fantastic. New modes, online for the first time. Definitely brought a lot of win to the table

2: Halo:Reach- game looks better by the day and is definitely turning out to be the pinnacle of the series.

3: DKC: More nostalgia factor, but there were some cool stylistic things going on. The night levels and other stuff felt very modern and cool.

4: LBP2: all new stuff. New ways to make levels. I found the first one to be pretty constricting. Really cool demo levels. Psychidellic shooter level ftw!

5: Kid Icarus: Biggest surprise for me. Even more surprising was that it would be in 3d and that part where he is flying with the lazers let me imagine it to its full potential.

Post your top 5 with brief explanations and we'll try to get a cumulative tally going.

honorable mention goes to pilotwings. I just saw the pics.

Wow, looks like console winner was 3ds.

MGS3, pilotwings, RE5. icarus wowee zowee

1. Kid Icarus Uprising (N3DS)

2. The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword (Wii)

3. Metroid: Other M (Wii)

4. Donkey Kong Country Returns (Wii)

5. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D ( N3DS)... Is it TRUE???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????... :O

Nintendo won this year...

I honestly think Sorcery should get a mention, it was the most impressive motion controlled offering at E3 in my opinion and it worked really well. If the game get's a little more time, it could be something to surprise us all later on.

1- Zelda:Skyward sword

2-Twisted Metal

3-Kid Icarus

4- DKC

5-Sorcery

Those made the most impact game wise imo.

Thou...why oh why not a wii Icarus...sigh...

It needs improvement. Right now, it looks a bit amateurish, but I'm sure it has time. It did really surprise me, though. Between that and Socom, Move doesn't appear to be a hard choice.

The Zelda game wasn't impressive at all, it was actually the most disappointing game out of the whole conference. Metroid: Other M didn't even look that great, I'd replace it with Epic Mickey or Kirby.

i think 3d icarus will be much better honestly. it blew me away.

I honestly think that Sony need's to back the development team with a bigger budget and give them some backup from Team ICE, they have potential and I can see the game being praised down the line. Move is actually looking to be a good purchase.

1. Gears of War 3

2. Enslaved

3. Kirby's Epic Yarn

4. Epic Mickey

5. de Blob: The Underground

honorable mention goes to I Am Alive thanks to new trailer and Bulletstorm for Fire in the Hole.