I'm going to side with the Move since i saw no reason to buy the kinect but thats my opinion whats yours.

I think move since it has more functionality within games - you can move your character with the navigator. Dont know how natal can be used for, say, FPS or RPGs or how you can accelerate or break in car games...

Who will sell more? Dunno.

But Kinect has infinitely more potential, while Move is "just" literally a Wii HD. It remains to be seen the response of the market, and also if developers will grasp the potential of Kinect after this initial wave of Wii game ripoffs.

I think move because developers will be able to create game for both Wii and PS3 without too much trouble while Kinect is too different.

move

Honestly, I don't know. PS Move is just a Wii on steroids and while Kinect has a lot of potential the lack of controllers will be a turn-off for most gamers, even those who Wii actually atracts.

The best thing would be a mix of traditional motion controllers and the Kinect camera, something we won't see until next gen kicks in late 2011/2012.

ps move because 1) sony actually has a good price for it 2) move has hardcore support 3) demos were significantly better than Kinect's and 4) Kinect at 150 would be wayyyyyyyyyy too high

PS Move.  Sony's got the momentum and it's going to pass 360.

Depends on how Kinect is supported by developers - - - innovation or cashgrab?  With the facial/voice recognition and the way they are marketing it, I think there's just way more potential there.  

I can see kids clamoring for the animal game and my nieces are going to eat up that dancing game like crazy.  But I just don't get who the Move is for.  

SO I vote for Kinect, but I don't really see either being runaway difference-makers/successes right out of the gate.  I just think Kinect will be more influential longterm/into the next gen.

The market for games using motion controllers is already 65M strong, so... I think publishers will tend to want to make Wii/PS3 casual games over Kinect casual games.  The Wii/PS3 SD-HD difference won't matter so much for casual titles -- it really comes down to raw cross-platform marketshare.

That said, I don't think there will be much software support for Kinect, casual or otherwise.

Move for certain.  The software library will matter.