Nintendo  - 10/10 (ZELDA and 3DS - epic win)

Sony - 9.9/10 (Kevin Butler, Twisted Metal, LBP2 and Sorcery)

MS - 5/10 (Ummm... Halo! Ummm... TIGERS! Ummm.....  That's all? Oh yeah Xbox 360 Slim)

True, but they still showed an amazing line-up for it and good games for their current platforms as well. Even without the 3DS, they would still have done very well.

Nintendo hands down their conference was amazing, followed by Sony and far behind Microsoft. 

It's a sad point of fact that people expect those with partiular console alliances to vote for their aligned console manufacturer.

It's another sad point of fact that people who are relatively unaligned will be unfairly labeled due to their judgment on the conference.

But you know what?

Nintendo took it. Hard.

Nintendo > Sony > MS

NINTENDO

Donkey Kong Country Stole The show!

Nintendo: 10/10

home run. nothing more to say. maybe the best e3 conferences i have seen.

Sony: 7/10

first half: meh at best, second half: WOW. newell being there was THE surprise of the e3 (so far?), and the twisted metal reveal was a perfect finish.

EA: 7/10

just a great show, with games games games.

Ubisoft: 5/10

THAT was the definition of "meh". highlight was rayman reveal, but the rest was just.... meh

Microsoft: 4/10

two huge mistakes: they started with the good stuff but had no big finish (well, the new model was a good ending i guess, but they should have had some hyped games leading to that...), and they promised to finally show core games for kinect, but didn't. instead they were showing their take on all the good selling casual games that are out.... and a star wars game that looked okay, but not great (waiting for more on that one).

one word  ... 3DS

OOT remake in 3D = no contest.

You're such a ninty-fanboy! Anyone who don't vote for Microsoft are obvious fanboys!