I'm not exactly sure what this poll's about, so I'm going to look at their profiles from a few different angles and see what I find.
Attitude Style: Dtewi's attitude is more ... I don't know... sinister, simmering and waiting to erupt, while Seece's is more just blunt and in-your-face. I think Dtewi's attitude has more style. Dtewi wins.
Most Bans: Dtewi has 5 bans (1 in 2010, 3 in 2009, and 1 in 2008), but Seece has 8 bans (1 in 2010, 6 in 2009, and 1 in 2008). Seece wins.
Most Friends: Dtewi has 33 friends. Seece has 23 friends. Dtewi wins.
Most Wall Posts: Dtewi has 1309. Seece has 4007. Seece wins.
Most Consoles: Dtewi has 6. Seece only has 1. Dtewi wins.
Most Sex Appeal: Dtewi is underage. Seece wins.
I'd call it a tie, but I'm voting for Dtewi because he dislikes Super Mario Bros. 3 and told me this on my wall several times, which means he's pure evil and criminally insane. And because Seece recently did a "Why are Nintendo fans angry about the Move?" thread, as if he hadn't noticed the 500 other threads on the same topic.
EDIT: Crap, I already voted for Dtewi before I found Seece's album of cat photos. That would've made it a tie again.