Rumours are going around that PS3 version has not been sent to reviewers yet.
Queue people on forums speculating PS3 version is inferiour. Hopefully someone here will be able to proove that is false.

its already received 6 perfect scores and nothing under a 9, sure ive never played it so i cant say if its overrated but from the looks of what i have seen the game looks masterfully crafted to the titties and the online looks like a small scale mmo.

ill be getting it at 9am tomorrow

http://www.nowgamer.com/news/3178/red-dead-redemption-360-amp-ps3-identical

Eurogamer gave this an 8 for both systems. Metacritic in all their wisdom have only given the 8 to the PS3, there is no score for the 360... Still, got this on pre-order. I really think this will be the GOTY this year but it is very early.

rockstar has said that the game was worked on for both consoles at the same time, so essentially there is no port both versions were made for their console, if there is differences there will be pros and cons for each side and the ps3 version has exclusive content probably due to the size of the bluray.  im sure the ps3 version will have more languages and things will be less compressed plus solomon sollys gang hideout(exclusive location) and a new outfit

Doubt that it's so "inferior"

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/reddeadredemption?q=Red%20Dead%20Redemption

If you look now on IGN,Gamepro etc they have now put up a note saying they have not yet received the review version of the PS3 game. It appears nobody has thus this report from nowgamer looks a bit less credible.

Someone out there must have this game on PS3 by now and can let us know the deal. I got it pre-ordered for my PS3 so would be cool to see if these rumours all over the net are just fanboy rubbish.

Nowgamer...

They proved to be a trusty website in the past.

This is Rockstar, they'll make sure both games are identical

Sorry mate i can't believe Rockstar would send the PS3 version to them over the other publications. I had never heard of them before and on the other forums seems others question their reliability. If IGN say there is no version then i believe them, they are a bigger website i would think.

Someone on the Gamespot forums mentions that the PS3 version has a lot of slowdowns when you are in the middle of a big gun fight and can see the pop outs in this video which is the PS3 version being played by some german magazine or something

http://videos.videogameszone.de/v/0sOQHB1OjNn/Red-Dead-Redemption/10-Minuten-kommentierte-PS3-Spielszenen/