People are complaining about a 9.25? I aint even mad.

And this is why metacritic needs to stop not counting outliers. 7 for MH3 = lol

this.  I'm don't really agree with some of the things the reviewer said, but after all, it is his opinion, and a 9.25 is not a bad review.

Is red dead redemption a better game though?

Nice modnation racers score, this seems rally fun!

@ Big Boss and others, only one person complained about the score itself and he didn't even make that big of a deal.

It's with GI itself, because at least with Edge and IGN they have legitimate reasoning. Putting words in other peoples' mouths is idiotic and kind of makes y'all look like an ass.

PS. @ Doobie_wop, since when did Nintendo fans generally hate IGN? I've actually heard HD fanboys say that IGN is Nintendo biased.

Monster Hunter Tri got a 7?

That must mean that at 9.25, Super Mario Galaxy 2 must be the greatest game of all time.

Not really. RDR is 9.75!

That's only because there's going to be a bunch of gigantic RDR posters in a Gamestop near you. 

I'd peg it on "We can't give a Nintendo-exclusive game of the month! Find something else this month to like more!" And, with RDR being from a company known for "mature, edgy games", it's easy to give RDR a higher score, since it also should pander to our suckerbase more.