Havent played the reach beta but i didnt think too much of halo 3 to begin with. Thought twas the worst in the series.

disolitude said: CommonMan said: Way to go Dis, you made the perfect troll-magnet thread. lol, I see that now...but when I posted it I really thought there was no room for trolls in here. I mean, I didn't compare Halo to a Ps3 shooter, I didn't say its the best FPS game on the market, I didnt say MW2 is garbage compared to halo...etc.

All it takes in an opportunity to bash a game that so many clueless ones love to hate. 

disolitude said: CommonMan said: Way to go Dis, you made the perfect troll-magnet thread. lol, I see that now...but when I posted it I really thought there was no room for trolls in here. I mean, I didn't compare Halo to a Ps3 shooter, I didn't say its the best FPS game on the market, I didnt say MW2 is garbage compared to halo...etc.

I'm thinking of starting a thread and just calling it "Halo" and see what kind of results I get. But seriously, you said something negative(-ish) about Halo 3, and you didn't think that people would jump in here to "agree" with you? Shocking. . .

C'mon, this is a troll thread. Someone had to bring in modern warfare 2 into it :) it just wouldn't feel authentic without it

but seriously though, how does reach compare to tribes, I've been waiting years to ski in HD

i prefer halo 3. It honestly was a game that took alot more skill. its hard to win if you cant get control of power weapons and thats the way i like it. Halo reach is 2 steps backwards in my opinion.

See IMO Halo 3 has been shown up with Reach. Halo 3 was nothing more than map control. And there is very little strategy other than luck which can take away Map control.

i didn't like any halo until reach! it just seems so smooth.

Wrong. Ive played halo 3 probably more than anyone else on this forum and the statement you just said is completly wrong. I would consider my self quite good at halo 3 and gaining map control and weapon control takes skill. Yet even if you dont have them if you are good enough you can break the other teams control. it all just comes down to skill. Skill > Luck or anything else in halo 3.

Halo reach and Halo CE, 2, 3 are alike in that they both share the title Halo. Other than that they are so different it isnt even funny. Im glad that people like reach and good for them but most halo purists such as myself are less than pleased with the changes. Halo reach makes it easy for bad people to be just as good as "pro" players. It takes much of the skill out of playing halo.

How is this a troll thread???