By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Nintendo vs Sony vs Microsoft. Who'll win the E3 2010?

 

Nintendo vs Sony vs Microsoft. Who'll win the E3 2010?

Nintendo 178 30.80%
 
Sony 270 46.71%
 
Microsoft 83 14.36%
 
I'm not sure 46 7.96%
 
Total:577
S.T.A.G.E. on 05 May 2010
Kenryoku_Maxis said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:

People can say it is just an opinion of who wins, but E3 is always between Sony and Microsoft with huge updates and Nintendo trying to even compete on that level. I think Sony and Microsoft are going to totally show up Nintendo with their new motion controls this year, but also hope I am wrong because ive been waiting for years to be wrong about Nintendo. Sony and Microsoft will have a lot to show this year. It sucks Nintendos only top games this year will be The other M and Mario Galaxy 2 and i'm starting to doubt the other M is coming out this year.

Its funny how someone can be so obviously bias and claim to be pointing out someone elses bias.

I have yet to see anything come out of your mouth that wasn't trying to venerate Microsoft or belittle Nintendo.

I never pointed out anyones bias. If you didn't read properly, I stated I have been waiting for years to be wrong about Nintendo at E3. Last eyars E3 was a step up, but their performance 1st quarter 2010 was horrible in fulfilling any form of hype. Lets hope I am wrong in June so you may in some way feel vindicated.



Around the Network
S.T.A.G.E. on 05 May 2010
calvinandhobbes said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:

People can say it is just an opinion of who wins, but E3 is always between Sony and Microsoft with huge updates and Nintendo trying to even compete on that level. I think Sony and Microsoft are going to totally show up Nintendo with their new motion controls this year, but also hope I am wrong because ive been waiting for years to be wrong about Nintendo. Sony and Microsoft will have a lot to show this year. It sucks Nintendos only top games this year will be The other M and Mario Galaxy 2 and i'm starting to doubt the other M is coming out this year.

Nintendo has the 3DS to show! that is bigger than anything Microsoft and Sony have to show. If anything it would appear that Sony will have the most lacking show for E3. 

....sure. I'll look forward to seeing it. Sony will not have the most lacking show at E3....they and Microsoft are unveiling their motion controls, plus online updates, unveiling new exclusives and more. Nintendo will mark their 2.4 billion profit and show the 3D and a couple games.



S.T.A.G.E. on 05 May 2010
esdevilx said:
there are no doubt sony are winner

You definitely must think the cart drags the horse.



Khuutra on 05 May 2010
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Bamboleo said:

It sucks that the only top game this year for the 360 is Halo: Reach.

See how I can ignore many games too?

Um no. The 360 has a AAA for every quarter this year so nice try. The PS3 has had great titles out this year as well. I am satisfied with both. The first AAA to hit Nintendo this year is SMG2....care to dispute that?

Sure.

If you mean "AAA" properly, which is to say as a function of budget and sales expectations, then Monster Hunter Tri easily qualifies.

If you mean "AAA" erroneously, wich is to say as a function of perceived quality, then quite a few more games will qualify - that includes No More Heroes 2, Tatsunoko vs. Capcom, Sakura Wars: So Long, My Love, Red Steel 2, Endless Ocean 2.... I think the point is proven.



C_Hollomon on 05 May 2010

Sony will win like always



Around the Network
jarrod on 05 May 2010
puffy said:
3DS and Natal will be the big talking points of E3, so either Nintendo or Microsoft will take the most hype from E3. That's my definition of 'winning' as the amount something is talked about can be measured, whereas satisfaction with a conference itself is difficult to actually get a figure for.

Pretty much agreed.  I expect MS/Natal to win over the "industry press" thanks to their unparalleled stagecraft, PR and pandering.

Sony is going to come in last I think though.  Unless they have something legitimately new and big (PSP2?), I just don't think Move with it's casual knock-offs, and a bunch of PS3 sequels to lukewarm series (Killzone, inFamous, Resistance, LBP) can really push them over Natal/slim or 3DS/Zelda.



S.T.A.G.E. on 05 May 2010
Khuutra said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Bamboleo said:

It sucks that the only top game this year for the 360 is Halo: Reach.

See how I can ignore many games too?

Um no. The 360 has a AAA for every quarter this year so nice try. The PS3 has had great titles out this year as well. I am satisfied with both. The first AAA to hit Nintendo this year is SMG2....care to dispute that?

Sure.

If you mean "AAA" properly, which is to say as a function of budget and sales expectations, then Monster Hunter Tri easily qualifies.

If you mean "AAA" erroneously, wich is to say as a function of perceived quality, then quite a few more games will qualify - that includes No More Heroes 2, Tatsunoko vs. Capcom, Sakura Wars: So Long, My Love, Red Steel 2, Endless Ocean 2.... I think the point is proven.

If you see Monster Hunter as AAA then so be it. Tatsunoku vs Capcom is a great fighter but I cannot consider it AAA, I am getting SSF4 today and I don't even consider it AAA. It is a yearly rehash, much like the old titles before Street Fighter turned to Alpha. No more Heroes 2 is AAA?...I don't even consider the No More Heroes coming to the 360 and PS3 a AAA. On the 360 and PS3 those would be considered average games. What is my love?....Endless Ocean 2?....Come on man...just say Zelda, Metroid and SMG2 and save yourself the trouble.



Beuli2 on 05 May 2010

Why not wait UNTIL they make their shows, THEN discuss this? Discussing things before having any information holds absolute zero value.



Above: still the best game of the year.

S.T.A.G.E. on 05 May 2010
jarrod said:
puffy said:
3DS and Natal will be the big talking points of E3, so either Nintendo or Microsoft will take the most hype from E3. That's my definition of 'winning' as the amount something is talked about can be measured, whereas satisfaction with a conference itself is difficult to actually get a figure for.

Pretty much agreed.  I expect MS/Natal to win over the "industry press" thanks to their unparalleled stagecraft, PR and pandering.

Sony is going to come in last I think though.  Unless they have something legitimately new and big (PSP2?), I just don't think Move with it's casual knock-offs, and a bunch of PS3 sequels to lukewarm series (Killzone, inFamous, Resistance, LBP) can really push them over Natal/slim or 3DS/Zelda.

June couldn't come soon enough. I can't wait to see everyones face when Nintendo gets shown up....................................................again. You guys must think the Move is a joke.



Khuutra on 05 May 2010
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Khuutra said:

Sure.

If you mean "AAA" properly, which is to say as a function of budget and sales expectations, then Monster Hunter Tri easily qualifies.

If you mean "AAA" erroneously, wich is to say as a function of perceived quality, then quite a few more games will qualify - that includes No More Heroes 2, Tatsunoko vs. Capcom, Sakura Wars: So Long, My Love, Red Steel 2, Endless Ocean 2.... I think the point is proven.

If you see Monster Hunter as AAA then so be it. Tatsunoku vs Capcom is a great fighter but I cannot consider it AAA, I am getting SSF4 today and I don't even consider it AAA. It is a yearly rehash, much like the old titles before Street Fighter turned to Alpha. No more Heroes 2 is AAA?...I don't even consider the No More Heroes coming to the 360 and PS3 a AAA. On the 360 and PS3 those would be considered average games. What is my love?....Endless Ocean 2?....Come on man...just say Zelda, Metroid and SMG2 and save yourself the trouble.

I don't "see" Monster Hunter as AAA, it objectively is a AAA game according to budget allotment and sales xpectations. That's an objective thing, and MH3 qualifies.

The things you consider AAA, as a person who does not own a Wii, have nothing to do with the consensus of those who play the games.

I don't think you actually have anything useful to contribute to the discussion concerning the Wii's library.