Sorry Selnor, but unless Alan Wake gets F K in its coffee and a sinner's sandwich, it CAN'T top Deadly Premonition!  And, because you insist on being a shill for everything XBox platform, I have to stand by this comment.

OMFG forget GOW3, ME2, Last Guardian, Red Dead etc etc THIS IS THE GOTY............................? LOL

These threads are becoming a joke, really they are

Anywho OT: Good trailer but I doubt it will even touch RE4 level and I 'doubt' it's GOTY material ( I say doubt cuz the friggin game isn't out yet lol) so yes worse shit storm of a thread created today confirmed? the power of the ? is amazing

Dude, you are exagerating. I admit the game looks good, but your just

so lost in your own little fanboy world your completely ignoring other games

that have gotten the "GOTY" treatment. And how is it gonna blow away RE or SH?

Alan Wake would have to sell more than 2.7 mil copies on the 360 to beat RE5 sales.

Yeah the thread became a shitstorm for obvious reasons but selnor was reasonable under all the criticism at him so we should respect that, I do anyway. Lets hope the game lives up to the expectations now. 94 meta wouldn't be out of the question.

Yep after reading several more pages it 'looked' like he understood the errors of his ways and remarks earlier on, so that's a good thing and yep this is by all means the only game on the 360 that I 'personally' am interested in. So I hope it's a success as well

Danm, to many people take gaming way to seriously. The only game of the year that matters is your own.

On that note the ABSOLUTE, DIVINE game of the year is ME2, you know cause the nexteight months couldn't possibly change a resonable persons mind.

Yah and this trailer sux in my mind until I see on my plasma.

Not even a page of posts in and this thread already gets high jacked by fanboys.

All I can say is.........

SUCKERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I got a 360 and I CANT WAIT FOR THIS FUCKEN GAME!!!!!!

HELL YEAH!!!!!

Ps. If you make a thread like this on a sony exclusive on the sony forum, there's no doubt it wont get even half shit this thread already has....

LATERZ!!!

FUCKEN HELL MAN....

more than half the posts in this thread has got nothing to do with alan wake....

FUCKEN FANBOYS....

GEEZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!

To those of you saying that you're not fully sold on the gameplay, and the others saying that this can't touch RE4...
Lets put these two statements together to conveniently aid my point:
"I'm not sold on the gameplay of alan wake and there's no way this game can touch RE4".
Several things wrong with this.
(Let me preface this by saying that I loved RE4 and 5. I wasn't scared by 5 at all, but the extra layer of depth that the co-op adding made for hours of gameplay. Stringing combos with a friend was challenging, but it was the best feeling ever when you pulled it off...And that Wesker/Jill fight? Holy shit! Sinking the kicks and punches into Wesker...Satisfying.)
1. Resident Evil 4's gameplay wasn't very deep....At all. It boiled down to standing still, aiming, shooting (preferably in the kneecaps or head), and performing a finishing move on a enemy by pressing one button. There weren't any immediately ready melee attacks (save for the knife), no stealth elements or takedowns, but it was still great-leading me to my next point...
2. RE4 was all about atmosphere. The game relied heavily on setpieces and high-adrenaline gameplay sections. El Gigante', the Mofos with the Gatling Guns, the cage, the blind berserker. Remember the scene where a naked fleshy body jumps out of a human-sized oven and grabs onto you seemingly out of nowhere...The scared the crap out of me and it made me want to keep playing.
3. Alan Wake has atmosphere. Thought it might not be the same sense of desolation in RE4-knowing that just because you couldn't lay your eyes on anyone didn't mean many eyes were not laid on you-however, it seems just as atmospheric if not even more so.

I know this will result in many TL;DRs, but I just felt like explaining why we see this as such a great looking things. I know I left a bunch of points out, so if you've got anything to add please say so.

Dw selnor... another CRAZED PS3 Fanboy.... They've just shitted on this thread... but then again... whats new???

Guess you can only take comfort with the fact that threads like this, get hijacked by FANBOYS becasue of their INSECURITIES....