Kilzoned82 said: Fallout 3 and Oblivion are also on the PS3.

Finally, something we can agree on, Oblivion for PS3 should be on the list

Kilzoned82 said: selnor said: fighter said: Kilzoned82 said: fighter said: Kilzoned82 said: I request a number of polls to be conducted and the VGC community will decide which games are the best in each genre. Selnor does not respresent the VGC community. High rating Metacritic and Gamerankings games do not get their scores on merit. Money hats are involved. Best 5 HD games of this generation are: 1. Final Fantasy XIII (PS3 version) 2. God of War III (PS3 exclusive) 3. Uncharted 2 4. Uncharted 5. Heavy Rain Ok no one will agree with my list. Who agrees with selnor with any of his lists?   the professionals behind metacritics ? Metacritic websites are owned by Microsoft. Their lists of games are designed to favour the 360 over the PS3. GVamers have played lots of high rating games on the 360 which fell way short of their high review scores. high review scores of 360 excluysive games are rigged because they are very few and far between. Mass Effect 2 and Gears of War 2 are the only good games 360 has had released. What high rating 360 exclusive games have been released besides those two released in the last 18 months since Gears of War 2 's release? <<<< Selnor please answer that question for us. Mass effect 2 is only a console exclusive, it is also on the PC. PS3 has had the following exclusive games in the last 18 months simnce Gears of War 2 released. Killzone 2, Infamous,  Uncharted 2, Demon Souls,  Heavy Rain and  God of War 3. 6 exclusive games Selnor, exclusive to PS3 rated above 85 on metacritic. The same site you rave on about. 360 has had no high rating exclusive game above 85% average since Gears of War 2 released.   I will forever quote you in my sig. You are a winner in your very own category ! 2009 was a slow year for 360. Everyone knows that. But Forza 3 says hello. Left 4 Dead 2. Halo 3 is amazing. Mass Effect1, Gears 1, GTA4 LATD, Portal 2 and Forza 2 are all 360 exclusives above 90. How the hell is that 2 games? Exclusive games Selnor rated over 85% on Metacritic. Since November 2008, Gears of War 2's release. Your reading comprehension needs improvement. PS3 6 exclusive games scored over 85% on metacritic in the last 18 months. Could be more but the 360 games well it only has Forza 3. I forgot about that game it was not memorable. Halo 3:ODST was an overpriced DLC expansion pack that did not add much to the Halo 3 experience. Left 4 Dead 2 is on the PC as and is not a 360 exclusivbe game just like Mass effect 2. Exclusive 360 games scoring over 85% on metacritic in 2009 and 2010. Forza 3. That is all. One game versus 6 games on the PS3 in the last 18 months. PS3 has had better quality games than the 360 in the last 18 months

Choosing to call Forza 3 not memorable is well, right there a problem between me and you. We will never see eye to eye. Pc is a different market, and has no impact on 360 sales. If it does it's very very small according to games sales.You base PS3 good games on the last 18 months, but forget the years before that. 360has had great games. As for 2009, 2010 360 especially in 2010 is awesome.ME2, SCC, AW, HR, Fable 3, Possibly Gears 3 and Rare have hinted at Killer Instinct 3. These are all titles destined for 85+ At least 4 should get 90+

Kilzoned82 said: Gran Turismo 5: Prologue is the best HD racer. Burnout Paradise is better on the PS3. Grid, Pure and Grid not on the list and are better on the PS3. No Motorstorm: Pacific Rift. Metacritic score do not mean anything. PS3 has the best games in every single category of games over the 360 except for Western RPGs and shooters. Forza 2/3 and PGR 3/4 are average games.

Leave it to someone named "Killzoned" to be objective, right?

I love the logic. Review scores and sales are not indicators of quality! Only PS3 fans can truely tell you what a great game is. Not "professional reviewers." Not gamers, who decide with their wallets. Because clearly, if they knew quality, they'd be playing PS3 games, right?

What kills me, Selnor, is that you almost had a meaningful thread. You were so close but then you added an illogical little addition that everyone will focus on instead of the actual meat or intent of the thread. You had to know people would disagree with you calling one version of the same game better based on a few points in an aggregate site where the difference is usually caused by a difference in what sites reviewed each version.

fighter said: Kilzoned82 said: Bayonetta is also on the PS3. Gee selnor update the lists properly. Multiplatform games and you make them out to be exclusive games.   have you checked reviews for Bayonetta on PS3 ? Yuck....

that is one game that i definitly agree that should be there under Xbox 360 only :)  (PS3 version is also very good especially after the patch but not as smooth as X360,,,while playing it on X360 i noticed that there are no visible screan tears and there are plenty on PS3 version)

Torillian said: What kills me, Selnor, is that you almost had a meaningful thread. You were so close but then you added an illogical little addition that everyone will focus on instead of the actual meat or intent of the thread. You had to know people would disagree with you calling one version of the same game better based on a few points in an aggregate site where the difference is usually caused by a difference in what sites reviewed each version.

So you are not locking this one then even though it's clearly flamebait?

 

Yeah, I know, I shouldn't even get involved and just ignore threads like this. Console wars are for fanboys. True fans of gaming own all current systems. Denying yourself the pleasure of some good games just because they are on the console of a company you don't like is a sign of stupidity.

great for you guys! this thread is awesome. (not)

I have not played Bayonetta. I have God of War III that is the best game because it is a PS3 exclusive game and the graphics and game play is so much better than Bayonetta.

Bayonetta is the best hack n' slash on the 360 but its also on the PS3. I saw no difference between the two versions of the games on Youtube. Looked like the exact same game to me.

seriously, this should be locked >_>

Tough there are a couple of issues with the list ( like the Ultimate Box being a re-release ) its one of your better topics For one, I never even realised that there are actually that many high rated RTS games on consoles or just how skewed the JRPG/WRPG genre is on the PS3/360...