I read your posts about Heroes of Newerth and decided to do a simple League of Legends vs Heroes of Newerth google search. This is what I came up with:
http://www.1up.com/do/feature?cId=3175835
http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/genmessage.php?board=954437&topic=50585338
http://www.gamasutra.com/php-bin/news_index.php?story=25734
I decided, from what I read, that I still like League of Legends better, though I will try Heroes of Newerth to make sure. These are the things I've noticed:
- League of Legends is developed by Steve Feak, the primary designer of DOTA all-stars. Not the only thing that matters, but is a plus.
- League of Legends is remarked as an evolution of DOTA, where Heroes of Newerth is said to be a remake.
- League of Legends has more unique champions, while many in Heroes of Newerth are retreads of DOTA champs.
- League of Legends userbase is more friendly while HoN userbase are more elitists.
- HoN has more polish, for still being in beta, but LoL is improving rapidly. Many of the things I am reading from a few months ago has already been fixed.
- League of Legends has low system requirements and is free to play. This has already helped bring in many of my friends to the game who would not have played it otherwise. Ensures a larger userbase.
- Free to play vs. Pay to play shows more promise. Free to play games recieve a lot more revenue over a longer period of time than the alternative. LoL has already showed they are willing to use the money to make meaningful updates.
- In LoL, PvP is important but not the end-all. I prefer this, cause I usually play tank supporting character is these types of games. Most games like this underpower tank supporting characters. I don't see that in LoL. Also, the team who gets the most kills is not necessarily the team that wins (though it helps a lot).
- LoL seems to be more creative and lighthearted in it's character/level design. This creates some very unusual champions and creates it's own style for the game.
Not to say HoN doesn't have some nice features. It is currently more polished and has more features than LoL. However, I will stick with LoL (and Demigod) mainly for now.