Barozi on 06 October 2019
Probably Gears 2 even though Gears 1 and 3 are equally awesome. I'm about halfway through Gears 5 and it's just as excellent. They're all in the 9/10 or higher range.
Only Gears 4 and especially Judgment are definitely worse.
But as someone else said, it depends on what you're looking for. I'm almost exclusively looking at SP here, but there are some MP modes that are better in Gears 4 or Judgment.
