Yes, I'm that guy who doesn't like GTA. Have your laugh and get over it.
Anyway, I was wondering if RDR2 isn't just some 'GTA with cowboys' because it looks fairly interesting (which I also thought of GTA). The game looks good but seems to share some gameplay mechanics from previous Rockstar games. I don't want it to be another Do-whatever-you-want simulator because I prefer an interesting story too.
I'm on the same boat. GTA is a"jack of all traits, master of none" kind of game as far as I'm concerned. I've heard the story for the first RDR is pretty excellent, but I wonder if the gameplay is a bit more focused than the GTA series