Pemalite said:
JWeinCom said:
To qualify as an atheist would have to require more than simply lacking a belief in god. I just ordered a sandwich. Is the sandwich an atheist? I'm sure we'd agree that the sandwich completely lacked any belief in god.
|
Sure. However... A Sandwich is an inanimate object, you are conflating the issue now to be something it's not.
A Theist is someone who has strong beliefs in a particular something, I.E. God. An Atheist is someone who lacks belief in that same something. I.E. God.
Ergo... Everyone that isn't a Theist is essentially an Atheist. That means a new born baby is an Atheist, it is the default position. Doesn't matter if they lack the cognitive capability to think along those lines either... Because I have worked and looked after allot of people with debilitating disabilities who would never be capable of grasping Theistic principles, they still fall under the Atheist descriptor.
|
Well, I'm not trying to conflate anything, I'm trying to clarify
You said you'd consider a pig an atheist, but your current definition seems to exclude that. Is a pig an atheist, or does it have to be a person?