By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Ali_16x said:
KLAMarine said:

These are some bold claims, Ali. Especially considering how you dismiss the importance of counting.

And now let's put one of your claims to the test by counting and we'll be using the help of axumblade, a user who runs most-wanted threads that count most-wanted titles through votes submitted by users of this very site.

 

September: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=220010

NX+WU+3DS: 1+3+4

PS4+PSV: 10+1

XB1: 5

PC: 1

 

October: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=220917

NS+WU+3DS: 1+3+2

PS4+PSV: 12+1

XB1: 4

PC: 2

 

November: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=222156

NS+WU+3DS: 1+2+2

PS4+PSV: 13+0

XB1: 6

PC: 1

 

December: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=223146

NS+WU+3DS: 3+2+1

PS4+PSV: 15+0

XB1: 4

PC: 0

 

January: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=224227

NS+WU+3DS: 4+1+2

PS4+PSV: 16

XB1: 2

PC: 0

 

February: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=225493

NS+WU+3DS: 5+1+1

PS4+PSV: 14+1

XB1: 2

PC: 1

 

March: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=226345

NS+WU+3DS: 9+1+1

PS4+PSV: 12+0

XB1: 2

PC: 1

 

April: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=227331

NS+WU+3DS: 7+0+1

PS4+PSV: 13+2

XB1: 2

PC: 0

 

May: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=228116

NS+WU+3DS: 6+0+1

PS4+PSV: 15+1

XB1: 1

PC: 1

 

Most-wanted title counts by brand from September of last year to this past May:

September: Nintendo: 8 PlayStation: 11 XBox: 5 PC: 1

October: Nintendo: 6 PlayStation: 13 XBox: 4 PC: 2

November: Nintendo: 5 PlayStation: 13 XBox: 6 PC: 1

December: Nintendo: 6 PlayStation: 15 XBox: 4 PC: 0

January: Nintendo: 7 PlayStation: 16 XBox: 2 PC: 0

February: Nintendo: 7 PlayStation: 15 XBox: 2 PC: 1

March: Nintendo: 11 PlayStation: 12 XBox: 2 PC: 1

April: Nintendo: 8 PlayStation: 15 XBox: 2 PC: 0

May: Nintendo: 7 PlayStation: 16 XBox: 1 PC: 1

 

...Doesn't seem very Nintendo-dominated at least as far as axumblade's most-wanted threads are concerned... I think this flies in the face of:

Ali, don't be so quick to dismiss counting...

 

Big thanks to

Excellent work axumblade! That's a lot of counting!

Cuphead is looking good but holy shit is it taking forever for it to come out.


Well there seems to be a miscommunication, what I meant be "dominated" was that the top games are most Nintendo games, which they usually are. Also, of course PS4 is going to have the most, it actually has multiplats LOL, and it also has the most exclusives. So the PS4 having the most is going to happen.

In that case, yes. It's not unusual that a Nintendo title grab the top spot in these lists. Nintendo has some very strong IP but understand that it's not like Nintendo fans can vote for an uber-hyped non-Nintendo title for the Switch. Red Dead Redemption 2 is not coming to Switch nor is Persona 5 or Final Fantasy XV.

Overall, a greater number of PS4 titles rank in these most-wanted lists than any other platform meaning PS4 titles are likely showing up with the greatest frequency in user votes than any other platform. This suggests that there is a higher number of PS fans than any other fanbase. This runs counter to the claim that

Ali_16x said:

Majority of the fans on this site of Nintendo fans.