Horror games don't really scare me. I play them more for the atmosphere. In fact, that's how I decide which games I want to get. I watch videos to see how the games look.
They don't scare me either, yet half the fun is gone on a second playthrough. I hardly ever replay games if I already know what is going to happen. I even found unlocking the map in BotW too much of a spoiler so stopped using the towers. Spoiler free reviews are enough to decide on games for me, I want to be surprised and make my own discoveries while playing. Take a chance, be surprised, it's fun going in blind.