While i overall preferred TLOU to UC4, i actually think UC4 was superior as far as gameplay goes :p It's the first time I've had active praise for the gameplay in an Uncharted game (both in design, and in general). For UC2 and 3, my praise was mostly limited to "it does what it needs to do to deliver on its purpose".
Ah well, each to their own.
Only relatively to TLOU, guys. . I still think it has the best gameplay among the Uncharted trilogy. But they followed the same Uncharted tired formula because it was only an Uncharted game so they couldn't really do a modern game like TLOU was.
They wasted 3.5 years of their precious time in doing an old school Uncharted game when they could have done TLOU2 which has much more potential. Now we just have to wait another 3 or 4 years in order to play TLOU2. They should have left Uncharted where it was, on PS3.