some of the quotes:
"MGS4 is special in so many ways that I suspect it will reside among the videogame industry's greatest achievements long after we're dust."
"a game deserving instant recognition on any all time top 10 list"
5/5
with editor's choice award
http://www.ps3forums.com/showthread.php?t=140663
some of their previous reviews of PS3 exclusives:
Resistance 8.5/10
Heavenly sword 8/10
warhawck 6.5/10(the lowest score for the game)
lair 5/10