S.Peelman on 05 April 2015
Tough question, since they're so similar. I have 1, 5 and 8 and have played 2 and 4, but that was only a couple times and a very long time ago. I also have DS, but this is about consoles. Don't know much about 4 anymore but I remember 2 being great though.
From those I have I like the first because of it's novelty and the single player mode. Mini-game Island remains a good idea. I like 5 because of it's mini-games. The Ice Hockey bonus mini-game kicked ass. I like 8 because of it's local multiplayer, which had a large variety of options with a collection of good boards to boot. I played that one the most, so I'd probably say Mario Party 8 is the best one.
